Best jewelry stores in Indianapolis: find options near you
Indianapolis boasts a rich tapestry of culture and commerce, and among its many treasures are the premier jewelers that cater to a variety of tastes and styles. Whether you are searching for a stunning engagement ring, elegant earrings, or unique custom pieces, the city offers a diverse range of options that meet high standards of craftsmanship and customer service. These shops are not just places to buy jewelry; they are destinations where artistry and personal expression come together.
With a blend of established boutiques and innovative new brands, the local jewelry scene reflects the dynamic spirit of Indianapolis. Each establishment is known for its distinctive offerings and commitment to quality, ensuring that every client finds something truly special. From timeless classics to contemporary designs, the selection showcases the creativity and expertise of talented artisans, making it a perfect locale for those seeking to adorn themselves with exquisite pieces.
1. Diamonds Direct Indianapolis
Tuesday: 10:00–15:00
Wednesday: Closed
Thursday: 10:00–19:00
Friday: 10:00–19:00
Saturday: 10:00–18:00
Sunday: Closed
Diamonds Direct Indianapolis offers an exceptional experience for anyone in search of exquisite jewelry. The customer service is outstanding, with attentive staff who genuinely care about helping clients find their perfect piece. From engagement rings to special anniversary gifts, the team ensures each customer feels valued and understood.
The craftsmanship is equally impressive, with skilled jewelers dedicated to creating stunning designs. Whether upgrading a cherished ring or choosing a new one, clients can trust that they will receive top-notch quality and artistry. This establishment is highly recommended for anyone looking to make memorable jewelry purchases.
2. Reis-Nichols Jewelers
Tuesday: Closed
Wednesday: Closed
Thursday: 10:00–18:00
Friday: 10:00–18:00
Saturday: 10:00–17:00
Sunday: Closed
Reis-Nichols Jewelers offers an outstanding shopping experience characterized by personalized service and exceptional knowledge. The staff is not only friendly but also dedicated to helping customers make informed choices, ensuring every visit is memorable. From exquisite jewelry to luxury watches, their selection is impressive and well-curated.
Customers consistently praise the professionalism and attentiveness of the team, making it a top choice for those looking for quality pieces. Whether you are a seasoned collector or shopping for a special gift, Reis-Nichols Jewelers is sure to exceed expectations with their expert guidance and welcoming atmosphere.
However it was very easy and quick in the Indianapolis location on 86th. I called in before purchasing and Nicole was very kind to help me on finding the perfect present and hold the item. She texted me back with options and it was very easy to communicate. Went in 2 days after putting the item on hold and purchased. Definitely recommend this location over greenwood.
Nick gave me an initial tour of the store the week prior and provided a ton of insight and support. This was my first major watch purchase, and Nick’s wisdom and thoughtfulness was extremely reassuring and welcoming.
After trying on maybe 25+ watches between the two store visits, we decided on the Tag Heuer Link Calibre 5 41mm. I couldn’t be happier for it to be my first luxury watch purchase. I’ve loved the Tag brand since I was a kid.
I will certainly be coming back for more watches from this location in the future as I start my collection and couldn’t recommend Aaron and Nick enough.
3. Midland Arts & Antiques Market
Tuesday: 10:00–18:00
Wednesday: 10:00–18:00
Thursday: 10:00–18:00
Friday: 10:00–18:00
Saturday: 10:00–18:00
Sunday: 12:00–17:00
Midland Arts & Antiques Market is an incredible destination for those seeking unique treasures and collectibles. With a **vast selection** of items spread across multiple levels, visitors can easily spend hours exploring various booths and displays. The organization of the market makes it easy to navigate through an amazing variety of antiques and vintage finds.
The atmosphere is both inviting and enjoyable, providing a **relaxing shopping experience** for all types of collectors. Prices are generally reasonable, and the staff is friendly and ready to assist, making your visit even more pleasant. Overall, it’s a fantastic place to discover one-of-a-kind pieces that you won’t find anywhere else!
The only reason I gave 4 instead of 5 stars is I got lost upstairs. I couldn’t find the stairs down as it’s not marked AT ALL and I promise it’s not simple to find. Once you’re there, you’ll immediately get what Im saying. It took me almost 7 minutes to figure it out. That doesn’t sound bad, but if you’re in a rush or need the restroom…it’s a problem.
I highly recommend you go check the place out. It was relaxing and fun outside of the Twilight Zone experience I had upstairs!
4. Shane Co.
Tuesday: 10:00–19:00
Wednesday: Closed
Thursday: 10:00–20:00
Friday: 10:00–20:00
Saturday: 10:00–18:00
Sunday: 12:00–17:00
Shane Co. offers an exceptional experience for anyone looking for high-quality jewelry. The staff is dedicated to providing a comfortable atmosphere where customers feel valued. Their careful attention to detail ensures that every client leaves satisfied with their choice, making the entire process enjoyable and stress-free.
The variety of options available is impressive, allowing customers to explore a wide range of styles and designs. With a focus on creating strong relationships with clients, customer service stands out as a top priority, making Shane Co. a trusted destination for future jewelry needs.
5. Windsor Jewelry
Tuesday: 10:30–17:30
Wednesday: 10:30–17:30
Thursday: 10:30–17:30
Friday: 10:30–17:30
Saturday: 10:30–17:30
Sunday: Closed
The service at Windsor Jewelry is truly exceptional. From the moment you step in, the staff demonstrates a commitment to customer satisfaction that is hard to find elsewhere. Each piece of jewelry is crafted with care, ensuring not just beauty but also quality that lasts.
What sets Windsor apart is their genuine attention to detail and personalized approach. Customers leave feeling valued and appreciated, knowing they’ve chosen a jeweler that prioritizes their unique visions. Windsor Jewelry is the go-to destination for those seeking both fine craftsmanship and an outstanding shopping experience.
We initially approached Jeremy to help design our custom wedding bands, and we were blown away by his attention to detail and commitment to bringing our vision to life. He listened to our ideas, offering valuable insights and guidance throughout the whole design process. The end result was beyond our wildest dreams.
Windsor Jewelry also takes wonderful care of my grandmother’s engagement ring, ensuring it remains as stunning as the day it was first worn. Their dedication to quality give me the peace of mind knowing that such an important heirloom is in capable hands. Every time we bring in the rings for cleaning, they make sure to check the prongs to ensure the stones are secure. I wouldn’t trust anyone else with something so important.
In addition to their exceptional service with jewelry, Windsor Jewelry also helped us with a special request, a watch for the wedding. Their extensive collection of watches, coupled with their genuine desire to make our big day even more memorable, resulted in the perfect choice that matched our rings, and our vision perfectly. They also managed to keep it a surprise to me! They treat each customer like family, going the extra mile to ensure complete satisfaction.
If you’re in search of a jeweler who combines exceptional craftsmanship with genuine care and attention to detail, look no further than Windsor Jewelry. They have exceeded our expectations in every way, and we cannot recommend them highly enough. We are absolutely customers for life!
6. Silver In the City
Tuesday: 10:00–18:00
Wednesday: Closed
Thursday: 10:00–20:00
Friday: 10:00–20:00
Saturday: 10:00–20:00
Sunday: 10:00–18:00
Silver In the City is a delightful destination for unique and charming gifts. With a wide selection of items ranging from seasonal decorations to beautiful jewelry, this shop never fails to impress. The atmosphere is warm, welcoming, and perfect for a leisurely shopping experience.
The staff at Silver In the City are exceptionally friendly and genuinely eager to assist customers. Their dedication to customer satisfaction adds a personal touch that makes every visit enjoyable. For anyone looking for the perfect gift or a special treat for themselves, this shop comes highly recommended.
If anyone reads this, succulents look good in just about any accent decor pot, and this store sells some for cheap.
10/10 experience would recommend to anyone. It was an online order, they shipped fast, they personally thanked me in a card (it’s a nice touch), everything was well packed.
It’s exactly what you want in an online ordering experience, the personalized touch was a bonus
7. Twin Jewelers
Tuesday: 11:00–19:00
Wednesday: 11:00–19:00
Thursday: 11:00–19:00
Friday: 11:00–19:00
Saturday: 11:00–19:00
Sunday: 12:00–18:00
Twin Jewelers offers an extraordinary selection of jewelry that impresses with its high-quality craftsmanship and stunning designs. Customers are consistently drawn to the remarkable beauty found within each piece, reflecting a true dedication to detail and excellence.
The service provided by the staff at Twin Jewelers is exceptional, characterized by warmth and professionalism. They guide clients through a seamless shopping experience, ensuring that everyone leaves satisfied with their perfect jewelry piece. A visit here is highly recommended for anyone seeking beautiful adornments and outstanding customer care.
8. Gold And Diamond USA
Tuesday: 10:00–19:30
Wednesday: 10:00–19:30
Thursday: 10:00–19:30
Friday: 10:00–19:30
Saturday: 10:00–19:30
Sunday: 12:00–19:00
Gold And Diamond USA is an exceptional destination for anyone looking for stunning jewelry at competitive prices. Their extensive collection ensures that every customer finds something unique, while the knowledgeable staff provides excellent recommendations tailored to individual styles.
In addition to their beautiful pieces, they offer top-notch repair services for jewelry, watches, and even phones, making it a convenient one-stop shop. The friendly atmosphere and efficient service leave customers thoroughly satisfied, making it a must-visit for all your luxury needs.
They did such a fantastic job, too! One set had to be unsoldered and then soldered back together, and it looks better now than it did before. Plus, the price was very reasonable. If I ever need more jewlery repaired or altered, I would absolutely go back.
9. Jared Jewelers
Tuesday: 09:00–18:00
Wednesday: Closed
Thursday: 10:00–20:00
Friday: 10:00–20:00
Saturday: 10:00–20:00
Sunday: 11:00–18:00
Jared Jewelers excels in providing a truly exceptional customer experience. Their knowledgeable staff are dedicated to helping you find the perfect piece of jewelry tailored to your needs, ensuring personalized attention throughout the entire process.
The warm and inviting atmosphere at Jared Jewelers makes it easy for customers to feel comfortable and valued. Whether you are shopping for a special occasion or simply treating yourself, their professional service will leave you delighted and eager to return for future purchases.
10. Barrington Jewels
Tuesday: 10:00–19:00
Wednesday: 10:00–19:00
Thursday: 10:00–19:00
Friday: 10:00–19:00
Saturday: 10:00–18:00
Sunday: Closed
Barrington Jewels offers an exceptional experience for anyone in need of jewelry services. With a focus on customer satisfaction, their attentive staff goes above and beyond to ensure you find what you need. Whether you’re shopping for a ring or looking for repairs, the level of service is consistently outstanding.
Their expertise in custom jewelry creation is particularly impressive, showcasing a deep understanding of design and personal sentiment. Visitors have shared positive experiences, highlighting the quick turnaround and quality craftsmanship. Anyone seeking reliable jewelry services will find a welcoming atmosphere and skilled artisans at Barrington Jewels.
I lost my step mother 3 1/2 years ago to cancer. Then I lost my dad suddenly 2 weeks ago. I had both their rings and a design idea in my head. I dropped them off on Monday hoping I could have the custom pendant by next week so I could wear it at GenCon and have them close to my heart. They had it done in 4 days and I purchased a beautiful sturdy but delicate chain for it. All at a very reasonable price.
This piece means so much to me. I can’t thank them enough.
I want to especially thank the jewelry repairer, Bug, she went above and beyond to ensure my satisfaction. Not only did she fix my necklace, but she cleaned my necklace too, so now it shines like never before. I also want to thank Laney for excellent customer service! Thank you Barrington Jewels for your outstanding service!
How to find your ideal jewelry store at the best price in Indianapolis?
Request help now to find the best price:
- Fill in the details and tell us what you're looking for
- We locate the best jewelry store in Indianapolis near you
- The company contacts you
Catalog of services offered by jewelry stores in Indianapolis
Custom Jewelry Design
Jewelry stores in Indianapolis often provide custom jewelry design services. This allows customers to create unique pieces tailored to their specifications, whether it be an engagement ring or a personalized gift. The skilled jewelers work closely with clients to choose materials, styles, and designs that reflect individual taste.
Jewelry Repair Services
Jewelry repair services are essential offerings at many stores. Whether a piece is damaged or needs resizing, expert jewelers can restore items to their original beauty. Common repairs include fixing clasps, re-stringing pearls, and repairing broken chains.
Engagement and Wedding Ring Selection
Choosing the perfect rings is a significant aspect of wedding planning. Jewelry stores in Indianapolis specialize in engagement and wedding ring selection, providing a range of styles, from classic diamond solitaires to modern settings. Knowledgeable staff can guide couples through their options to find the ideal symbol of their love.
Watch Repair and Maintenance
Many jewelry stores also offer watch repair and maintenance services. This includes battery replacements, band adjustments, and comprehensive servicing to ensure that timepieces function accurately. Proper care and maintenance can extend the life of a watch considerably.
Jewelry Appraisal Services
Jewelry appraisal services are available for those who wish to determine the value of their pieces. Certified appraisers evaluate items based on quality, materials, and market demand. This service is essential for insurance purposes, resale, or estate planning.
Stone Replacement and Upgrades
For clients looking to enhance their jewelry, many stores offer stone replacement and upgrades. This service entails replacing damaged or outdated stones with new, more vibrant ones. Jewelers can recommend various options, from diamonds to colored gemstones, to elevate the look of a piece.
Jewelry Cleaning and Polishing
Regular maintenance is crucial for preserving a jewelry piece's shine. Jewelry stores in Indianapolis frequently provide jewelry cleaning and polishing services, ensuring that pieces look their best. Specialized solutions and techniques are used to clean both precious metals and gemstones effectively.
Estate Jewelry Services
Estate jewelry refers to previously owned pieces, and many jewelry stores specialize in estate jewelry services. This includes buying, selling, and appraising estate pieces. These services provide a unique opportunity for with the rich history and craftsmanship of older items.
Gift Wrapping and Custom Packaging
Gift wrapping and custom packaging are thoughtful services offered by jewelry stores for special occasions. Customers can choose elegant wrapping options and personalized boxes, making their gifts even more memorable. Such services help enhance the overall gifting experience.
Frequently asked questions about jewelry stores in Indianapolis
What types of jewelry can I find in Indianapolis stores?
Jewelry stores in Indianapolis offer a wide variety of jewelry types, including engagement rings, wedding bands, necklaces, earrings, and bracelets. Additionally, many stores carry handcrafted pieces, designer jewelry, and antique items. Whether you are looking for fine jewelry or costume jewelry, there are options available for every taste and budget.
How do I choose the right jewelry store in Indianapolis?
Choosing the right jewelry store involves considering factors such as reputation, customer service, and the quality of their products. You can start by reading online reviews and asking for recommendations from friends and family. Visiting stores in person allows you to assess the atmosphere and speak with staff to gauge their knowledge and helpfulness.
What should I expect when shopping for an engagement ring?
When shopping for an engagement ring, you should be prepared to explore different styles, shapes, and metal types. It’s important to have a budget in mind and be aware of the Four Cs: cut, color, clarity, and carat weight of diamonds or gemstones. Many stores offer custom design options, allowing you to create a unique piece that reflects your partner’s style.
Are jewelry stores in Indianapolis able to perform repairs?
Yes, many jewelry stores in Indianapolis provide repair services for items such as broken chains, ring resizing, and stone replacement. It is advisable to inquire about the store’s repair capabilities and estimated turnaround times. Some stores may also offer cleaning services to keep your jewelry looking its best.
What is the best way to care for my jewelry?
Caring for your jewelry involves several important practices. Always store your items in a cool, dry place, preferably in a jewelry box or pouch. Avoid exposing your jewelry to harsh chemicals and remove it before engaging in activities that may cause physical damage. Regular cleaning with a soft cloth and using appropriate cleaning solutions for specific materials can maintain the shine and quality of your pieces.
What is the difference between custom and ready-made jewelry?
Custom jewelry is designed and created specifically for the client’s preferences, making it a unique choice. Ready-made jewelry, on the other hand, is mass-produced and available in various styles. Custom pieces typically allow for greater personalization, while ready-made items are often more affordable and readily accessible.
Can I negotiate prices at jewelry stores in Indianapolis?
Negotiating prices at jewelry stores is common, especially for larger purchases. Many store owners are open to discussions about pricing, especially if you are purchasing multiple items or high-value pieces. However, it’s important to approach negotiations respectfully and be aware of the store’s policies regarding discounts and pricing.
What types of gemstones are popular in jewelry?
Some popular gemstones used in jewelry include diamonds, emeralds, sapphires, rubies, and amethysts. Each gemstone has its own characteristics and meaning, and the choice of gemstone often reflects personal style or significance. Additionally, semi-precious stones like topaz, aquamarine, and citrine are also popular choices.
Are the jewelry stores in Indianapolis knowledgeable about ethical sourcing?
Many jewelry stores in Indianapolis are increasingly aware of the importance of ethical sourcing and may carry items made from sustainably sourced materials or conflict-free diamonds. When shopping, it is wise to ask about any certifications or standards the store follows regarding the sourcing of their materials. Transparency in these practices is becoming more common as consumers seek ethically made products.
What is the return policy for jewelry stores?
The return policy for jewelry can vary significantly from store to store. While some shops may offer a standard return period for unused items, others may have restrictions on returns for personalized or custom pieces. It’s essential to ask about the store’s return and exchange policies before making a purchase, ensuring that you understand any conditions that may apply.