Best insurance agents in Indianapolis: find options near you

Shawn is the absolute best to work with. He is extremely knowledgeable and truly cares about each of his customers. He offers great insight into your current needs and provides the full picture of options. This office has been great to work with as well. Victoria answers my phone calls and is so friendly and ready to help if she can, where you may not have to go through Shawn to complete a certain task. I love the option of when renewals come they voluntarily review your policies with what all is offered among their book of business carriers to see if there is a better premium or coverage benefits that would be better suited for you. Plus they handle everything if you choose to move your business to a new carrier, they handle 100% of the paperwork and you’re just signing in the end. It’s such a streamlined process that you won’t feel even 1 teeny bit of an ounce of stress. It’s THAT streamlined of a process! Thank you again Shawn for helping me and also helping my parents in $600+ in savings! Truly I’m one grateful customer!!

My experience with Gabe has been great. Even though I didn’t end up using them the first year we communicated, Gabe reached out one year later just before my old policy expired. He re-shopped insurance plans for us and we were able to make the switch and save money. Communication has been very easy, and our new plan started without an issue. I appreciate that they will re-shop multiple providers every year, giving you the best chance to save money at renewal time.

My husband and I just switched insurance to Scott Wenclewicz Insurance Group, and the process was flawless and professional. Justin Zipperian took his time explaining the difference between coverages and made us feel like we were on top of things. Justin quoted our automobile & homeowners insurance, and, of course, we were skeptical that they could do any better than our current provider. He provided us with a very detailed quote and options to fit our specific needs, and I couldn’t believe how much more we were paying in our current insurance. Justin was able to save us many dollars on our car insurance and homeowners’ insurance. We are so grateful for his thoroughness and the time he spent with us to ensure we have the best plan for our needs. I would recommend Justin to any of my friends or family.

Gabe has been great to work with. He is always responsive, professional, and takes the time to clearly explain all my insurance options so I can make the best decision. He helped me find good coverage at a very competitive price and made the whole process simple and stress-free. I really appreciate his honesty and reliability. Highly recommend Gabe if you’re looking for an insurance agent you can trust!

Shawn was extremely helpful and patient in assisting me with various home & auto quotes as a first-time home buyer. He took the time to ensure that I was getting the best deal and helped make the entire process smooth & efficient. I highly recommend Shawn and Scott Wenclewicz insurance group!

I have had a great experience with this insurance team. Justin Zipperian was able to expand and add coverage for my home and auto, while actually saving me money. He went through all the details thoroughly with me. I feel well taken care of. I recommend them and him highly!

I just want to take a moment to give a huge shout-out to Shawn Meier at Scott Wenclewicz Insurance Group. He’s been absolutely amazing to work with – always professional, quick to respond, and genuinely looking out for my best interest. Every time I reach out for a quote, he finds the best coverage at the best price, and he does it fast. On top of that, he’s just easy to talk to – great conversations, no pressure, and it always feels like he truly has my back. I really appreciate the level of service, honesty, and care that Shawn brings to the table. Highly recommend working with him and the whole team at Scott Wenclewicz Insurance Group!

If you’re looking for an insurance agent who truly cares, Cristobal is the one to choose! From start to finish, he was incredibly patient, calm, and understanding — even when I wasn’t at my best. His professionalism never wavered, and he took the time to explain everything in a clear, informative way that actually made sense. Cristobal went above and beyond to make sure I felt confident and supported throughout the entire process. You can tell he genuinely wants the best for his clients, not just to make a sale. That level of dedication is rare and appreciated. I highly recommend Cristobal to anyone who wants top-tier service, honesty, and someone who will truly advocate for them. He is hands down exceptional!

I just started a new insurance policy and the process was very smooth. My policy agent is Lesley and she is phenomenal at what she does. She helped me get the right insurance I was looking for.. guided me with information, customer service oriented, and highly kind not to mention she was very patient. People like this make the world go around you guys are lucky to have her. Ps. She deserves a bonus and a raise.

Christobal has excellent customer service skills! Very relaxed demeanor. Collected all necessary information and provided a very afford quote for my personal situation. All was said in done in around 38 minutes! Would recommend to others.

Cristobal was amazing! Over the phone and in person. My friend was having a bad day and was quite rude. Chritobal handled it with ease. Amazing customer service and got me all the way right!

I called Freeway Insurance this morning to update my policy, and Cristobal Martinez made the entire process so easy and smooth! He walked me through all of my options clearly and was incredibly friendly the whole time. Excellent customer service — he’s truly great at his job! Highly recommend working with him.

Good rates! Will help get all the discounts you can, no rush will explain everything to you step by step and answer any questions you have! Cristobal Martinez is amazing to work with 10/10 recommendations

Cristobal was a great agent to work with. Very knowledgeable and communicative throughout the whole process. Very good customer service over the phone. He was also very patient as the process took up some of our time but he got it done and i was satisfied with his service. Great Agent Cristobal.

My meeting with Julie Corcoran was very informative today. Her explanation and break down of the Medicare options was great. She is super knowledgeable. I’m so glad I met with her. I feel much better about the switch to Medicare. Thank you!

We met with Avery today who provided an excellent and very professional review of our Medicare plans. There was absolutely no pressure and he in fact suggested delaying changing plans until our birth months which may provide an advantage. We had a similar review two years ago with a different broker who quickly lost interest when we were not interested in an Advantage plan. It is easy to understand why Easy Street has nothing but 5 star reviews.

We’ve used Easy Street for Medicare consulting. Sandra is very professional and extremely knowledgeable. She comes prepared and answers all of our questions and concerns. We are totally pleased with this company and their employees. I would highly recommend them for any of your insurance needs!

Avery is excellent helping people with their insurance needs. Signing up for Medicare, part B, supplemental plans & all other things is a stress free process. He ask about what you are looking for in a plan, medications, etc. Then with his expertise recomends a few plans that best fit your needs. Then signs you up. It’s easy, with Easy street.

Had our appointment today with Sandra as my husband wanted to change plans. He got a text the day before confirming the date and time of the appointment as well as what documents/information to bring. Sandra had great suggestions after talking about what things were most important him, and he picked a plan he really liked. I can’t say enough great things about Sandra: she’s extremely knowledgeable, kind, listens well, and is very approachable. We highly recommend her and the rest of the staff at Easy Street Insurance.

Justin was recommended to us. They had all kinds of good, great things said about him !! Spot on . He is so accessible and patient! Knows so much about the insurance industry for Medicare. Really works so hard to make sure we get the right plans for each of us. Always available to answer questions when needed. Feels so good knowing he’s helping us through our Medicare journey!!!!

My husband and I handle all important matters on behalf of my father in law. When we recently found out that an important prescription medication was no longer going to be covered by any Medicaid plan in 2026, I immediately called Sandra at Easy Street. She had helped us in the past and in a matter of minutes Sandra was able to find a very cost effective solution. We still get to use the best plan and she found a source for this particular medication, that turns out is actually cheaper than what my father in law was paying in 2025. Sandra knows her stuff! It’s important to have someone you can trust who is so knowledgeable that can help find the best solutions to keep out of pocket costs down, especially for seniors on fixed incomes. Thank you Easy Street! You’ve taken the stress away!

I have been with a different insurance company for over 15+ years but I was always curious about how much I was spending on home and auto vs other insurance companies. A buddy of mine told me about Wenclewicz Insurance and how fast and affordable their rates were. I reached out to Doug Stahly and setup a meeting for the next day. After a few conversations to answer all of our questions my wife and I switched over our home and auto insurance. The process was easy and straightforward. We will save hundreds of dollars per year by simply switching. Doug and the team have been very quick to answer any and all questions and we look forward to being their customers moving forward!

What a great find! We have used Wenclewicz since moving here several years ago for our home and auto insurance. They have been great to work with, always looking for what works best for our Insurance needs. I usually talk with Callahan and he is very good about going over our policies and answering any questions that I may have for him. He is thorough, pleasant, and professional. Each year, when we renew, he listens to us, does the research, and finds the best policy, for the best price for us. Highly recommend them!

Callahan has been absolutely wonderful to work with. He has been quick to respond and pays attention to the details. He is great at making sure you understand exactly what you are getting with the insurance policies and takes his time explaining them to you. We did not feel rushed or an inconvenience in any way. We are appreciative of all the hard work this office has done for us already. Thank you!

They saved us money on both our home owners policy and our auto policies. When someone hit our car in the parking lot, the provider took care of us at a superior level. Wenclewicz Insurance has great service. Our agent, Callahan, has been attentive, helpful and extremely knowledgeable. Highly recommend!

Having an independent insurance professional performing research for our home, auto, and umbrella insurance needs has been a relief. Wenclewicz Insurance Is responsive, thorough, and professional. They have provided us with peace of mind when trying to make sure we have sufficient coverage at reasonable prices.

Working with Wenclewicz is super easy and once the policy is in place, they check every year to ensure you’re getting the best rate/value based on your needs. I highly recommend them. Save your inbox all the spam and let Wenclewicz do the shopping around for you.

Wenclewics insurance is great! They shopped for competitive rates and found me a great rate. Lora is good at following up and communicating with questions and suggestions to keep me up to date. They are all so friendly and helpful!

I had an impressive experience working with Heather! She was incredibly proactive and attentive throughout the entire process. Her communication was clear, efficient, and reassuring every step of the way. She helped walk me through what needed to be done. Heather truly went above and beyond to make sure everything was handled quickly and accurately. I greatly appreciate her professionalism, responsiveness, positive attitude. Heather made me feel like family. ♥️ I highly recommend Heather at Steffey Insurance.

I’ve had an outstanding experience with Elizabeth and the entire team at Steffey Insurance. They are consistently responsive, kind, and go above and beyond to meet our needs. Whether it’s answering questions, resolving issues, or helping us navigate our coverage options, their service is always prompt, efficient, and effective. They always exceed our expectations. I highly recommend them to anyone looking for a reliable and customer-focused insurance provider.

Heather was fantastic to work with as we transitioned to a new policy when selling our home. There was an error on the side of our closing agency, and Heather worked patiently to help us figure everything out! Would highly recommend Steffey and working with Heather!

Jackie was fantastic to work with! She’s extremely prompt and quick with follow-ups, and I was able to reach her right away. She’s friendly, knowledgeable, and makes the whole process smooth and stress-free. Truly excellent customer service. I highly recommend!

I’m so happy to have found Steffey Insurance! My agent, Allison Morse, is so incredibly helpful and keeps all the policies I need in order. She is quick to answer questions and provide needed solutions. I’ve had a wonderful experience with this agency and plan to stick around for a long time!

I highly recommend Steffey Insurance! I can’t say enough good things about our agent, Jackie Spohrer. She is always so friendly, attentive, and quick to help with any needs or questions I have. Every time I talk with her, she manages to brighten my day. It’s rare to find someone who not only provides excellent service but also makes the experience such a positive one. Steffey Insurance is a wonderful company, and Jackie truly goes above and beyond!

Heather Lukemeyer is a wonderful account manager! She will take the time to hear your needs and make sure she is getting you the best fit for your insurance.

Royal gave me the best customer service, first time getting insurance and he was really helpful explaining things even to a newbie like me. I really appreaciated his patience in answering my questions and answering them throughly. Would highly reccomend him. Thank you so much if you read this Royal!

I have been working with Jeff for all my vehicle insurance needs for the last few years! I have sent him many referrals, and everybody has always been really happy with him. He’s personable, knowledgeable & quick, and has always given me amazing rates and answers any and all questions I have with patience. I will never use another insurance company.

I had a terrible experience with Jeffrey That works off Emerson. Had multiple big mistakes that cost me a lot of money; luckily after talking to their support team was able to give me a refund after months of this person messing up my policy. That’s why I’m giving them two instead of one star. Don’t think it’s a bad company, but if you’re going here do not go through anyone named Jeff !!!

Got my SR22 quick and easy with the help from my homie Royal !! He hooked me up with a nice quote I appreciate the great service bro thank you

I just wanna tell you about Royal. He is a great Insurance Broker who is patient, kind an eager to help you find the best policy. Thanks, Royal.

Jeff was great. I got a great price and was explained exactly what coverage I had. I will refer people to him in the future. Thank a lot!

5 stars for Royalveer Khangura it only took him a few minutes to resolve my issue and was easy to talk to would definitely recommend.

I’ve had a fantastic experience with Breneman Insurance Group! Their team has been incredibly helpful and prompt every time I needed to modify my coverage, whether it was adding supplemental home insurance or updating my vehicle coverage. They made the process so easy and straightforward. Most recently, I had to submit a claim for wind/hail damage to my home, and I couldn’t be more impressed with the service. They took the time to explain the entire claims process in detail and always responded to my inquiries quickly. The Erie Insurance Adjuster assigned to my claim was amazing to work with—they even negotiated directly with my roofer, which made the entire process seamless and stress-free for me. I really appreciate their professionalism and dedication to making things as easy as possible. Highly recommend Breneman Insurance Group for anyone looking for reliable, customer-focused insurance services!

Breneman Insurance saved me about $500 per month in total on my home, auto, and umbrella policies. Zach was great to work with and gave me a lot of peace of mind about making the switch after decades with my other company.

I just recently switched insurance agents to Breneman. I didn’t have any association to them before this time except my son recommended them. I gave them all my information so they could give me a competitive quote. To my delight they were able to reduce my annual cost for home, auto and umbrella policies by $904/yr. Pretty awesome right! If you are competitive shopping or new to insurance, I highly recommend you give Breneman a try!

Zach and his team have been amazing!! They helped us find amazing coverage with even better rates. We couldn’t be more happy with their service. Thank you Breneman Insurance Group for helping us find better rates for our car insurance and homeowners insurance.

We were so happy to work with Zach. He was super knowledgeable and explained several options to us so that we ended up with homeowners and auto policies that were exactly what we needed. Our previous insurance had risen significantly over the last two years even though we’d not had any claims. He saved us a significant amount of money and even improved our coverage. Would highly recommend Breneman Group.

We reached out to Zach for a home and auto insurance quote and were quickly provided with an estimate offering better coverage across the board at a substantial savings. I highly recommend reaching out to Zach for a quote to see what he can do for you!

I recently had my vehicle stolen, Zach and his staff were immediately working to help me, making calls and helping me along the way! My current provider decided they wanted to double my auto rates because of my vehicle being stolen. Erin shopped different providers, taking her time, looking at it from all angles. Erin found another major provider that kept my auto rates in the same ballpark and same options. It has been a great experience with the agency, I would recommend them to anyone looking for a new agent or agency.

Ashley at Conner Insurance was awesome to work with. She gave me several options, explained everything clearly, and made sure I understood what I was getting. She found me a great price and was always quick to respond anytime I had questions. Ashley really took the time to make sure everything was right and made the whole process easy and stress-free. Highly recommend working with her!

have had a wonderful experience with Ashley Brown from Conner Insurance. Her professionalism, patience, and attention to detail made me feel safe and well taken care of at all times. She answered all my questions and guided me step by step, making everything very easy, especially considering my limited English. I am very happy with her service and I highly recommend her to anyone looking for reliable insurance and exceptional service.

We were referred to Connor Insurance by our mortgage company and had the pleasure of working with Ashley Brown. Ashley was exceptional. Not only did Ashley help us save over $1000 on our home and auto premiums, but also took the time to explain what we needed for our specific situation. They were also very quick to make changes to our plan when we purchased our new vehicle. I highly recommend Ashley and Connor Insurance to anyone looking for a better insurance plan.

I worked with Ashley Brown and she was AMAZING. Ashley was my advocate from the beginning. She explained everything to me in great detail, was always available when I had questions and found the best insurance for me. I would recommend this to anyone!!

Ashley Brown at Connor Insurance helped me switch my home and auto coverage and saved me over $200 a month. She shopped multiple options, explained everything clearly, and made the process easy. Highly recommend giving her a call if you think you’re overpaying.

Ashley Brown did a great job with my home and auto insurance needs. She saved me a bit of money and found me better coverage. Ashley was super helpful and easy to work with.

Had a wonderful experience working with Haley Rose! Haley streamlined the process for us to ensure we received adequate coverage at the best available rate. Would highly recommend working with Haley in the future.

Shanna has been an incredible help in navigating insuring our car and our house. She has made it extremely easy from helping us find the correct policy to ensuring a reimbursement went through. It’s been incredibly easy working with her and everyone at the office. Couldn’t be happier with the team.

I reached out to get insured with State Farm and they put me through to an agent. Although I did not qualify for State Farm my agent Theresa, kept in contact with me for over several weeks to make sure that I would be able to get insured with a good company. I now have good auto insurance and Theresa made sure to answer any questions I had about the process. She was very helpful and very kind. My experience couldn’t have been better thanks to her.

Megan Barrow recently helped me enhance my coverage, and I couldn’t be more satisfied. Megan patiently explained my options and customized a plan to meet my increased coverage needs while respecting my budget. Thanks to Megan, I now have the peace of mind knowing I’m well protected. I’m incredibly grateful for her assistance. Megan Barrow is the insurance agent you can trust to genuinely care about your well-being and provide exceptional service.

I worked with Theresa over the phone. My previous auto insurance agency stopped serving Indiana and I needed a new policy and fast. Theresa understood my needs and my price range and helped me through the process. I got quotes from other companies online prior but having an actual, caring human on the other end really made the process so much better. Give Megan’s office a call if you’re shopping for insurance for sure!

When I made the decision to get Life Insurance I really thought this process would be morbidly serious and scary. However that was not the experience I had with Teresa! She was caring, knowledgeable, funny she was really a ray of sunshine!! She answered all my questions and explained my policy in simple terms that I could understand. My policy is very affordable and also there was so many options available! I highly recommend this Insurance Agency to anyone who needs Life Insurance and all of your other insurance needs. I’m completely switching to State Farm for all my insurance needs, that’s how wonderful my experience was today. Thank you Teresa you are awesome!!

I would like to thank Shanna & Teresa for their support in assisting my husband & me. They made our transition simple & easy by patiently answering all our questions & explaining all the great benefits State Farm has to offer. Megan, I must say your team have the Best customer service skills & in today’s society that means alot! On a scale of 1 thru 10, we rate this company an 11+ Thank you!

I have been with State Farm for many years and have always had the best customer service! The last encounter was with Shanna, 5 stars for her too! Very professional and a huge help getting my new camper all set up.. made it very simple during a stressful time!!

I have had the best service with McGowan. I had to make changes in my policies earlier in the year and Tiffany took care of this for me. She made it very easy for me. And Sarah has always been helpful with my health insurance plan. They are the best!!

Amy R is the best. I have what I think is a lot of different insurance policies for our home and business. At my age I forget and sometimes need her assistance to figure it all out. Everyone at McGowan is very helpful and do what needs to be done to «get it done». AAA+++ Had a pretty large claim at one time and they were there for us.

We have been with this company for many years. Marcie is our rep we work with and she is wonderful. Always will to research the best prices for us. She is very courteous, friendly and responds promptly to any inquires that we make.

I have been a client of McGowan group since the days it was the Pfenninger Agency. I have always been satisfied with the way. They treat their customers. I know if I have any kind of issue. All I have to do is call and someone walks me through it or takes care of it. Also through the years I have occasionally decided it’s time to see if I can find a cheaper rate. Every time I have tried that it’s always been cheaper to go with McGowan or at least just a few dollars difference. I recently tried to compare them with these ones that are so advertise, GEICO and progressive. McGowan beat them hands down on the prices. I always trust them. I know I can rely on them.

When I went into their office, they weren’t sure if I needed the insurance or if they could find a company that would insure the RV car port we had installed to protect our travel trailer. I assured them that I still wanted to insure it and with a liability clause. They not only found an insurer, but at an extremely reasonable price. Thanks, McGowan insurance!

McGowan is prompt in assisting and being hands on when it comes to my personal and business insurance. If any issue arise the McGowan team takes time to walk me through everything step by step!!!! Thank you for your awesome service!!!!!

McGowan Insurance is always there and available for questions, or concerns. They are personable and professional people, I would and have recommended them to all my family and friends.