The Toy Pit

📍 Toy stores in Indianapolis

9.7

The Toy Pit is located in Indianapolis. Featured in the Toy stores category, it has a rating of 4.8. Check all the details here.

Features and services of The Toy Pit

From the business

  • Small Business

Service options

  • On-site services

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair-accessible car park
  • Wheelchair-accessible entrance

Crowd

  • LGBTQ+ friendly
  • Transgender safe space

Planning

  • Quick visit

Payments

  • Credit cards
  • Debit cards
  • NFC mobile payments

Children

  • Kid-friendly activities

Parking

  • Free parking lot
  • Paid parking lot

The Toy Pit is in position 1 out of 10 in toy stores in Indianapolis

Customer Reviews

★★★★★
★★★★★

The Toy Pit has a rating of 4.8 out of 5 based on over 1524 reviews on Google

Nayelli Rodriguez

If you are a collector or even just someone looking for a hit of nostalgia The Toy Pit is an absolute must-visit. They aren't just there to ring you up; they are genuine fans who make the visit feel welcoming and are very knowledgeable. The team went above and beyond to help me check out the figures and made the whole "hunt" amazing. The highlight was finding multiple S.H. Figurarts as they have a killer inventory. Definitely worth the trip and will be back for more.

Nayelli Rodriguez ☆ 5/5
Andrea Jones

My family traveled two hours one weekend to find this place back when it was their original location and were COMPLETELY amazed at how much cool stuff they had! It was unbelievable at the selection in such a small out of the way place. We made the trip a couple other times and the only complaint I had was we just didn’t have enough daylight to look at all of it in such a small space…Fast forward another couple years and we heard they moved to a bigger location. We made the drive and were SHOCKED at the amount of space and how we could still spend hours in the place that was all spread out and well lit and organized. Don’t get me wrong- the original was awesome but the upgrade is AMAZING! I recommend The Toy Pit to any person at all. The kid, the grown up kid, the kid at heart, the collector… I guarantee you will find something for everyone here! It is well worth the drive and my family will continue to come enjoy talking to the staff and finding treasures! I also think it’s awesome that these guys will even buy your toys and vinyl. You can sell some doubles to get some of your wish list wants and needs! Keep up the GREAT WORK! The place is AWESOME both inside and out! See you again next month!

Andrea Jones ☆ 5/5
Benjamin Baird

Always have a great selection and th best spot for funko pops and hard to find figures. Staff has always been friendly and helpful, special thank you to owner for helping me find a gauntlet that been wanting for years! Thank you👍🏾

Benjamin Baird ☆ 5/5
Brittany Stallcup

Such an incredible store! They have treasures old & new! I specifically went to buy legitimate LaBuBus & to buy one of my sons a birthday present & my oh my!! The selection! The vintage Barbie’s! Star Wars!! The funko pop selection! We could spend days in this store! They also buy things so that’s cool too because we are quite the collectors & have some duplicates we could part with potentially in the future 🤪 I can’t wait to spend more money here!

Brittany Stallcup ☆ 5/5
Michelle Lammert

Went here on a whim while visiting and I was not disappointed! This place had so many cool items. It was a complete blast from the past! I would absolutely recommend this cool little shop! They have awesome stuff and the staff was so friendly!

Michelle Lammert ☆ 5/5
Jim Meyer

I could spend hours here. Great selection of toys and collectibles of practically every genre. It’s where I’ve been restocking my Masters of the Universe collection and enjoying some pinball! There’s something for everyone here.

Jim Meyer ☆ 5/5
kenzie ravenwood

So many awesome nostalgia pieces! Should’ve taken more pics but I was too excited over all the Gremlins stuff. We easily spent an hour here looking at everything.

kenzie ravenwood ☆ 5/5
View all reviews

Information about The Toy Pit

Address

The Toy Pit is located at 3827 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46205, United States

Phone

The phone number of The Toy Pit is +1 317-703-8697

Website

The website of The Toy Pit is: thetoypitindy.com

Business Hours

Monday: Closed
Tuesday: 11:00–18:30
Wednesday: 11:00–18:30
Thursday: 11:00–18:30
Friday: 11:00–18:30
Saturday: 10:30–18:00
Sunday: 12:00–18:00

Contact The Toy Pit

    Similar alternatives to The Toy Pit

    Subir