The Toy Drop

This second-hand toy store is a total nostalgia hit! I was over the moon to find the exact toy I loved as a kid here—and to my surprise, it still works perfectly, just like I remembered. I can’t thank the store enough for bringing back such sweet childhood memories. If you’re after a blast from the past, this place is a must-visit!

Had a great time looking at childhood memories and found a couple things I never thought I would. Prices were good and so was the staff. Wonderful store!

Would absolutely sell to these guys again. They were very professional and accommodating to our schedule. They did buy-back on a Monday, which is hard to find. Paid in cash and have awesome stuff in store! We will def be back with our kids to shop for Christmas. Very friendly and knowledgeable staff. Thanks again!

Great place, awesome deals! Toys, trading cards, comics, and even more. Excellent staff and kind! Stop by and check them out!

great store with lots if insanely amazing stock and so clean and well organized. loved spending my money there on some choice gi joes! kim is amazing and so friendly!

The best vintage toy store in Indy! I regularly take in trades and make purchases for my Star Wars collection.

An absolute wonderful and friendly shop. It is extremely well organized. At no time did I need to dig through parts bins and try to figure out what is what. Items were individually packaged and sorted by year.