Best seafood restaurants in Indianapolis: find options near you
Indianapolis may be known for its rich Midwestern cuisine, but it also boasts an impressive array of restaurants specializing in seafood that cater to diverse tastes and preferences. These establishments offer a delightful escape for those yearning for fresh, flavorful dishes that highlight the ocean's bounty. From classic favorites to inventive culinary creations, the city's seafood scene is sure to satisfy even the most discerning palates.
As the culinary landscape continues to evolve, several top-notch dining options have emerged, establishing themselves as leaders in providing exceptional seafood experiences. These venues not only prioritize top-quality ingredients but also focus on delivering excellent service and inviting atmospheres, making them perfect for both casual meals and special occasions. Diners can indulge in a variety of exquisite dishes and explore the rich flavors that make Indianapolis a hidden gem for seafood lovers.
1. Rick’s Café Boatyard
Tuesday: 11:00–22:00
Wednesday: 12:00–21:00
Thursday: 11:00–22:00
Friday: 11:00–22:00
Saturday: 11:00–22:00
Sunday: 10:00–22:00
Rick’s Café Boatyard offers a delightful dining experience with its stunning waterfront views and exceptional service. The staff is incredibly welcoming, ensuring every guest feels right at home. The atmosphere is relaxing, making it an ideal spot for both casual meals and special occasions.
The menu features a variety of delicious dishes, complemented by expertly crafted drinks. With a commitment to quality and a focus on customer satisfaction, Rick’s undoubtedly strives to provide top-notch service that leaves a lasting impression. It’s a place that invites you to return time and again.
My sister and I actually went for our nephews big 40!! It turned out awesome. I believe the food was actually catered from elsewhere and was also very good. As usual the atmosphere was beautiful and the staff was helpful, available and very nice! There was also a 360 stand provided but I didn’t get the name of the company that provided it so I will just humiliate myself by sharing the video my sister insisted we make…I’ve been to Rick’s a few times and it’s a pleasure every time, I love the scenic view over the water.
The food… I really can’t speak much to this as I was not able to eat what I ordered. Specified no spicy whatsoever and I was served a dish that had so much hot pepper on it of some sort that I lost my taste for the remainder of the time. Another with us ordered the burger medium done and it was served well done. Though one of our meals was comped… Nothing was offered at the time when we had it available before we had to take it two hour drive home. Therefore, I left hungry.
Disappointed to say the least as I had the beautiful blessing of meeting up with my wonderful friend from Colorado. Which I’ll mention his salmon was also overcooked.
I’m not at all trying to complain I would love to bring the awareness up that when you have a location like this it is highly recommended to have a quality chef in the kitchen or checks and balances in place to help sustain the crowd that it’s going to attract.
In the events I am ever in the area and decide to go back it will only to be appetizers and maybe an easy drink to ask to be made.
The food was fantastic. The Oyster were plump, and just enough brine flavor. Amanda brought us extra horseradish on request.
I had a crab cake sandwich on a lettuce bed. WONDERFUL! The grilled asparagus was top notch.
I cannot wait to come back!
2. The Journey
Tuesday: 11:00–15:00, 17:00–21:00
Wednesday: 11:00–15:00, 17:00–21:00
Thursday: 11:00–15:00, 17:00–21:00
Friday: 11:00–15:00, 17:00–21:30
Saturday: 11:00–15:30, 17:00–21:30
Sunday: 11:00–15:30, 17:00–21:00
The Journey is a remarkable dining destination offering an exceptional buffet experience. Guests can indulge in a wide array of dishes, from savory seafood to hearty meat options, all of which are prepared with great care and attention to detail. The ambiance is inviting, ensuring a pleasant atmosphere for dining with loved ones.
The attentive and friendly staff elevate the service, making sure that patrons are well taken care of throughout their visit. With its delicious offerings and commitment to exceptional customer care, The Journey undoubtedly stands out as a place to enjoy great food and company.
The servers are paying good attention and cleaning your table every time I go to get more food.
Strong recommendation!
The food quality is outstanding, with a diverse selection that caters to all tastes. Everything is fresh and flavorful, particularly the succulent meats and delightful seafood options.
The staff is another highlight; they are friendly, attentive, and always ready to assist. Their welcoming nature truly enhances the experience.
In summary, The Journey in Fishers offers excellent food and service, making it a great spot for a meal with family or friends. Highly recommended!
3. Red Lobster
Tuesday: 11:00–22:00
Wednesday: 11:00–22:00
Thursday: 11:00–22:00
Friday: 11:00–23:00
Saturday: 11:00–23:00
Sunday: 11:00–22:00
Red Lobster consistently delivers an impressive dining experience with its exceptional seafood offerings. The staff is attentive and ensures that every guest feels valued. Many patrons rave about the delicious Cheddar Biscuits, which have become a signature favorite.
Alongside the well-prepared entrees, the efficiency of the service stands out. Diners appreciate the prompt attention and knowledgeable recommendations from the servers, making each meal feel personal and enjoyable. Red Lobster truly excels in combining quality food with stellar customer service.
4. Caplinger’s Fresh Catch
Tuesday: 10:00–18:00
Wednesday: Closed
Thursday: 10:00–20:00
Friday: 10:00–21:00
Saturday: 10:00–21:00
Sunday: Closed
Caplinger’s Fresh Catch offers an impressive selection of fresh seafood that truly stands out. The atmosphere is welcoming, and the staff consistently deliver exceptional service, ensuring a pleasant dining experience. Patrons rave about the generous portions and delectable flavors of each dish, making it a local favorite.
The commitment to quality at Caplinger’s is evident, with ingredients that are both fresh and sustainably sourced. Diners appreciate the clean environment and attention to detail, creating a trustworthy spot for seafood lovers. This establishment is definitely a place worth visiting for a satisfying meal.
Update: the owners sister Molly reached out and apologized about my experience, she mailed me caplinger gift card.
5. The Juicy Seafood Restaurant & Bar- Lake Cir Dr
Tuesday: 11:30–22:00
Wednesday: 11:30–22:00
Thursday: 11:30–22:00
Friday: 11:30–23:00
Saturday: 12:00–23:00
Sunday: 12:00–22:00
The Juicy Seafood Restaurant & Bar offers a welcoming atmosphere perfect for seafood lovers. The menu features a variety of delicious options, including fresh shrimp and mussels, all served with a touch of fun. Guests have reported a lively environment where the staff engages in enjoyable interactions, enhancing the overall dining experience.
Customer service is prioritized, with attentive staff ensuring that everyone feels valued. Many patrons appreciate their friendly treatment, creating a positive dining experience. Even when there are minor hitches, the overall vibe and quality of food lead many to return for more delightful meals.
hygienic place. We would and will go back again.
6. Seasons 52
Tuesday: 11:00–23:00
Wednesday: 11:00–22:00
Thursday: 11:00–22:00
Friday: 11:00–23:00
Saturday: 11:00–23:00
Sunday: 11:00–21:00
Seasons 52 offers an exceptional dining experience characterized by its seasonal menu that emphasizes fresh and flavorful dishes. The ambiance is elegant yet inviting, making it the perfect spot for any occasion. Guests can expect dishes crafted with care, showcasing high-quality ingredients that delight the palate.
The staff at Seasons 52 are truly a highlight, providing superb service that enhances the overall experience. Every visit brings attentive and knowledgeable servers, making meal selections and wine pairings a breeze. This restaurant consistently succeeds in delivering a memorable culinary journey.
Luis was our server, super friendly and very informative on the wine selections. I don’t drink much but I took the moment to indulge and I am so glad! Thanks so much for the amazing experience!
-Pros
Great quality of food
Great service
Great environment
Portion sizes are on the healthy side
-Cons
None
Again, I may be biased because this is one of my favorite places, but it’s good every time!
Quality of service: service was good. It was a little slow, granted I was there on a Saturday night during dinner, so it was packed.
Ambience: it’s a beautiful restaurant with bar in the middle of it.
Parking: restaurant has its own parking, but it gets packed.
Recommendations: Sparkling Flight, Butterfly Bliss Martini, Chipotle Potato Skillet, Mushroom Bisque,
7. The Juicy Seafood Restaurant & Bar- Castleton
Tuesday: 11:30–22:00
Wednesday: 11:30–22:00
Thursday: 11:30–22:00
Friday: 11:30–23:00
Saturday: 12:00–23:00
Sunday: 12:00–22:00
The Juicy Seafood Restaurant & Bar- Castleton offers a delightful dining experience with a focus on exceptional seafood dishes. The atmosphere feels inviting, making it an excellent choice for families or casual outings. Patrons often rave about the flavorful boil options that leave diners craving more.
Service here stands out, with attentive staff that elevate the dining experience. Guests have reported consistently phenomenal service, ensuring that every visit can be memorable. This restaurant truly sets the bar high for customer care while serving up delicious meals that seafood lovers won’t want to miss.
Went back again tonight. This time William was our server. And once again phenomenal food and service. Ya should set the industry standard on customer service.
The atmosphere felt a bit like being at an aquarium with an odd blue overtone & the ocean decore.
8. Bonefish Grill
Tuesday: 11:00–22:00
Wednesday: 11:00–22:00
Thursday: 11:00–22:00
Friday: 11:00–23:00
Saturday: 11:00–23:00
Sunday: 11:00–21:00
Bonefish Grill offers a delightful dining experience with a menu rich in fresh seafood and compelling flavors. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it perfect for both family meals and intimate dinners. Attentive service enhances the experience, ensuring guests feel valued and well-cared for.
The quality of dishes is exceptional, highlighting signature specialties like the Bang Bang Shrimp. With an array of delicious options and welcoming staff, Bonefish Grill sets a high standard for seafood restaurants, making it a must-visit for food lovers.
Calamari was the best.
Also got the Bang Bang Shrimp Eggs Benedict, Soo very good.
Highly recommend
9. Crab 99 Bar and Restaurant
Tuesday: 14:00–23:00
Wednesday: 14:00–23:00
Thursday: 14:00–23:00
Friday: 12:00–23:00
Saturday: 12:00–23:00
Sunday: 12:00–23:00
Crab 99 Bar and Restaurant is a fantastic destination for seafood enthusiasts. The atmosphere is delightful, making it a perfect spot for both casual gatherings and special events. The highlight is undoubtedly their crab dishes, which are not only fresh but also bursting with rich flavors. The attentive and friendly service enhances the experience, ensuring that guests feel welcomed and valued throughout their visit.
The menu offers a variety of delicious options, all prepared with care and skill. Guests rave about the creative cocktails that complement the food perfectly. With an inviting ambiance and outstanding menu, Crab 99 is a place where culinary delights meet exceptional service, leaving you eager to return for more!
The man was fast and I chose the Wednesday special.
The awesome waitress Barbee gave me a great recommendation, on how to see the shrimp.
It was so good that I tipped her 25% . I also had the brownie which is fantastic. I don’t eat ice cream so I got it without the ice cream and whipped cream.
I like it so much I would definitely visit this place again.
They have a very awesome and vast selection downstairs.
I asked to meet the owner and he was mad kool!
10. The Oceanaire Seafood Room
Tuesday: 16:00–23:00
Wednesday: 17:00–21:00
Thursday: 16:00–21:00
Friday: 16:00–22:00
Saturday: 16:00–22:00
Sunday: 16:00–21:00
The Oceanaire Seafood Room offers an exceptional dining experience characterized by its fresh seafood and attentive service. Guests consistently praise the quality of the dishes, which are prepared to perfection, providing a delightful array of flavors that truly impress. The ambiance complements the menu, creating a memorable atmosphere for special occasions and casual outings alike.
The staff is dedicated and quick to respond, ensuring every need is met with a smile. Whether you are celebrating an event or simply enjoying a night out, the exceptional customer service at The Oceanaire enhances the overall experience, making it a top choice for seafood lovers looking to indulge in a fabulous meal.
And that is saying something since we gravel the world over and I have probably had my own weight n lobster entrees. The chicken fried lobster is spectacular. Light, crispy, flavorful, moist and oh so good.
Also had a fabulous halibut with fresh peaches that melts in your mouth.
Elaine our server was attentive, friendly and quick.
Overall fantastic meal.
Chilean Seabass on Ramen is outstanding. Seafood tower for four was very affordable and well finished. Scallops grilled to perfection!!!!
How to find your ideal seafood restaurant at the best price in Indianapolis?
Request help now to find the best price:
- Fill in the details and tell us what you're looking for
- We locate the best seafood restaurant in Indianapolis near you
- The company contacts you
Catalog of services offered by seafood restaurants in Indianapolis
Freshly Prepared Seafood Dishes
Seafood restaurants in Indianapolis pride themselves on offering a variety of freshly prepared seafood dishes. From succulent shrimp cocktails to grilled salmon, diners can enjoy dishes made with high-quality ingredients that reflect seasonal availability.
Daily Specials
Many seafood restaurants feature daily specials that highlight unique and seasonal seafood options. These specials often include chef-curated selections, ranging from exotic fish to locally sourced shellfish, providing a chance for diners to experience something new and exciting each visit.
Oysters and Raw Bar Selections
For seafood enthusiasts, oysters and raw bar selections are a must-try. Indianapolis seafood restaurants often offer a diverse array of fresh oysters, served on the half shell, along with other raw delicacies like clams and shrimp. Diners can enjoy these fresh offerings with house-made sauces and accompaniments.
Seafood Soups and Stews
Seafood soups and stews are another highlight of many seafood restaurants. Dishes like clam chowder, lobster bisque, and cioppino provide a comforting option for those seeking a hearty meal. These dishes are typically rich in flavor and made with fresh, quality ingredients.
Grilled and Broiled Options
Many restaurants feature a selection of grilled and broiled seafood options, providing healthier cooking methods that enhance the natural flavors of the fish and shellfish. Patrons can expect expertly cooked items such as mahi-mahi, halibut, and sea bass, all drizzled with flavorful sauces or marinades.
Pairing with Wine and Craft Beers
Pairing seafood dishes with wine or craft beers is an essential service offered by seafood restaurants. Knowledgeable staff can provide recommendations for the perfect pairing, enhancing the dining experience with selections that complement the flavors of the seafood being served.
Takeout and Catering Services
Many seafood restaurants also offer takeout and catering services, making it easy to enjoy delicious seafood at home or at gatherings. Catering options often include platters of seafood, soups, and sides that can serve parties or special events effectively.
Family-style Dining Options
Family-style dining options are becoming increasingly popular in seafood restaurants. These dining settings allow guests to share large portions of various seafood dishes, promoting a communal dining experience. This is ideal for families or groups looking to explore multiple flavors and selections together.
Signature Sauces and Sides
Accompanying side dishes and signature sauces play a crucial role in the seafood dining experience. Many restaurants craft their own unique sauces, such as garlic butter, tartar sauce, or citrus aioli, alongside classic side dishes like coleslaw, rice pilaf, or seasonal vegetables to complement seafood entrees.
Frequently asked questions about seafood restaurants in Indianapolis
What types of seafood can I expect to find in Indianapolis restaurants?
Seafood restaurants in Indianapolis typically offer a diverse selection of fresh seafood. Popular options include salmon, swordfish, shrimp, and crab legs. Many establishments also feature local catches like catfish and perch, ensuring a range of flavors and cooking styles. Additionally, you might find unique dishes that incorporate regional ingredients.
Are seafood dishes in Indianapolis sustainably sourced?
The sustainability of seafood can vary widely by restaurant. Many seafood restaurants in Indianapolis are becoming increasingly aware of sustainable sourcing practices. When dining out, look for establishments that highlight their commitments to responsibly sourced seafood or those that participate in programs such as the Marine Stewardship Council. You can also inquire with your server about the sourcing of the seafood on the menu.
Do seafood restaurants in Indianapolis cater to dietary restrictions?
Most seafood restaurants in Indianapolis are accommodating when it comes to dietary restrictions. Many offer dishes that cater to various needs, such as gluten-free options, low-carb meals, and vegetarian or vegan alternatives. It’s always best to communicate your specific dietary restrictions to your server, and they can assist you in finding suitable dishes.
Is it common to find raw seafood dishes?
Yes, many seafood restaurants in Indianapolis offer raw seafood dishes, including oysters, ceviche, and sushi. These dishes are popular for their fresh flavors and unique preparations. If you plan to try raw seafood, ensure the restaurant has a good reputation for food safety and handles their seafood properly. Always check reviews or get recommendations from trusted sources.
What are some popular seafood dishes in Indianapolis?
Some of the most popular seafood dishes you might encounter include fried catfish, shrimp and grits, crab cakes, and seafood pasta. Many restaurants offer unique twists on classic dishes, showcasing local flavors and ingredients. Diners can also find various fish tacos and seafood boils that are particularly popular in casual dining spots.
Are seafood restaurants in Indianapolis suitable for large groups or events?
Many seafood restaurants in Indianapolis can accommodate large groups or private events. If you're planning a celebration or a business event, it’s a good idea to contact the restaurant in advance to inquire about group menus or private dining options. Some establishments offer special packages for larger parties to ensure a seamless dining experience.
How do I choose a seafood restaurant in Indianapolis?
Choosing a seafood restaurant in Indianapolis can be influenced by several factors. Look for reviews on platforms like Yelp or Google to get an idea of the dining experience. Consider the type of atmosphere you prefer, whether casual or upscale. Additionally, check for specialties or unique offerings on their menus that appeal to your palate.
What is the best time to visit seafood restaurants in Indianapolis?
The best time to visit seafood restaurants can depend on personal preferences and the specific restaurant's popularity. Typically, evenings and weekends see higher traffic. Visiting during off-peak hours, such as late afternoons or weekdays, can provide a more relaxed dining experience and potentially shorter wait times. Additionally, some restaurants may offer happy hour specials on seafood items during specific times.
Are there any seafood festivals or events in Indianapolis?
Indianapolis often hosts various food festivals that include seafood as a feature. Local events may showcase seafood tastings, cooking demonstrations, and chef competitions. Checking the city’s event calendar or local food blogs can provide information on these festivals, which are great opportunities to experience a range of seafood dishes in one location.
How can I ensure I'm getting fresh seafood?
To ensure you are dining on fresh seafood, consider several indicators. Look for restaurants that have a high turnover rate, indicating they serve many customers and are frequently restocking their fish. Observing the menu can also provide clues; establishments that change their offerings regularly based on what’s in season or fresh catch are likely committed to quality. Don’t hesitate to ask your server about the seafood’s freshness as well.