Prime 47- Indy's Steakhouse

The food was delish. Our server was so fun. Our group had a good time. My one critique for this upscale restaurant, the ladies room needs addressed. One toilet seat would slide and the other the whole toilet was unstable. 3 ladies at our table and we all 3 spoke on it. We were a bit surprises by that. Otherwise the experience was pretty good 🙂

We were in town for a huge conference and while considering where to make reservations, we chose Prime 47 over Capital Grille for the uniqueness of eating local. That proved to be an excellent decision! Service was excellent here! Our server (forgot his name, taller slim guy with mustache and we sat near the kitchen) was spot-on and knew how to take care of a larger party. He was always nearby, ready to help and his suggestions were welcomed, taken, and perfect! Their steaks were incredible! We tried a tomahawk, filet, and Delmonico and that was the best Delmonico I’ve ever had… the tomahawk was incredibly flavorful as well! Sides were great too… mac & cheese was so very tasty, so was the creamed spinach and mashed potatoes! Save room for dessert! They have an amazing bread pudding!! Their wine list was nicely done and it’s always great when you see the Wine Spectator’s seal/award on it! Nice prices on their wines too! Overall, this was soooo much better than the St Elmo chain (and Harry & Izzy's) excellent experience… We’ll definitely be back!

13th wedding anniversary in the books. Everything was absolutely amazing, from the food, to the service, the personalized anniversary menus, and the free cookie dessert - which was a very nice surprise! We started our dinner with the wagyu meatballs. They were huge, covered in melted cheese, and the tomato sauce was not extremely acidic. Very tasty. Our steaks had the perfect amount of chared taste to them. I had the 12 oz filet and my husband had the ribeye. The side dishes were astronomical! You could feed 4 people! We opted for the mashed potatoes and the very best macaroni and cheese I have ever had from a restaurant. Ignore the previous review when someone said the mac and cheese was mediocre. That's far from the truth! Just as we were ready to wrap it up and ask for the bill, one of our servers, Brian, said that our complimentary anniversary dessert was on the way. We also ordered the bred pudding, because.... why not? Bread pudding was warm and drizzled with caramel sauce and topped with chopped walnuts. Our anniversary dessert was a warm chocolate chip cookie topped with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. Both were phenomenal! Prime 47 is pricey. However, it was very well worth it. My husband and I both agree that we will return every March 31st to celebrate another year of marriage.

We had a nice time. It was our 1st time eating here. Devon was an awesome server!

The atmosphere was nice but the food was a whole mess. Got the world tour, Medium well….. Came out medium so I had to send it back while waiting on my steak to come back my brother ordered the Australian wagyu, medium….his first time ever trying wagyu It was rare….. had to call the manager over…. She downplayed it, said they didn’t want to over cook it. ATP I’m wondering why it’s not cooked to how we ordered ?????? Well my steaks come back the world tour,,,two are right the Japanese steak is still medium. I called manager lady over again. She told me I was particular,,, I said no I normally get steaks well done Ive been trying to go medium well the past few years but medium I can’t handle (I tried tho) She took it back a second time So my brother gets his steak back Same issue the edges are medium but the middle was rare AGAIN ….she took it back a second time… I thought steakhouses pride themselves on never having to send a steak back We sent ours back twice!! After all that they finally got it right. Wasn’t gonna leave a review till my stomach woke me up in the middle of the night. Diarrhea I spent over $600 and left unhappy

The service was great. After arriving there, we did not realize that we made reservations for the wrong location, The ladies at the front desk made accommodations even when they were busy. They could have just pushed us away, and they didn't. The food was also great. Amazing flavor and portions were perfect. Our server was great as well. When my husband ordered a new drink, he never tried, and he did not like it at all. The server adjusted our bill a little, which was unexpected and nice. We were not asking nor expecting that.

A tad disappointed with our anniversary experience overall. However, the staff did do an excellent job and presented a nice anniversary desert gift. This is probably a place will not be returning to because there was nothing really truly to write about that performed better than Ruth Chris - Capital Grille or St Elmo's. The other challengers have Prime 47 beat at this downtown location. When there are so many places to choose from - a person chooses to return to the places they had the best experiences. We had not given this restaurant a chance since the "piano" days and that to us was a fabulous selling point. Now its gone of course. The meal was good. The mushrooms, corn and even the steak were just par. The drinks were also par. We were impressed by how close the Shrimp Cocktail was to the best in the USA at St Elmos - very close, and probably the closest competitor in this area. The drinks were good, but nothing made them stand out -It was nice/pleasant and OK is how we both felt with the entire experience. When a couple spends 200+ dollars on a meal, really it should be special. Yes, it was a special night for us, and the staff did everything perfect-----it was all about the food here that kept this place from our overall hot list or local recommendation list. As a local city police officer for over 30yrs I must always be honest and ethical to guide everyone to the best of the city. That would be Capital Grille - St Elmos - Tonys - or the Oceanaire. Those are the spots where you want to go and be seen. Sorry that I must check the box below to say "no I cannot recommend Prime 47 to my friends, family or followers on social media, but still within the top 10-15 restaurants in the city. WARNING: Also do not make the same mistake: We saw PRIME 47 gift cards at Costco earlier this week and decided that would make a good place to go on our anniversary --Found out after our meal the cards are only good at CARMEL location - so read closely all PRIME 47 are not true