Best music stores in Indianapolis: find options near you

Post Road and E. Washington St.! This is the best karma store I’ve ever been to. They’re so organized and clean. The employees are absolutely wonderful! If they don’t have what you need in store, they’re always more than happy to help you get it even if it needs to be ordered.

Best record store in Indianapolis. If you love music you will love Karma Records. The Karma Records crew are welcoming and friendly. I’ve been going there for 25+ years since I was a kid and never had a bad experience. Everyone there is always great and helpful. If they don’t have what you’re looking for they will help you find it or order it for you. Also, this is the best place to go for the Record Store Days. They have all the best exclusive releases for Record Store Day and Black Friday Record Store Day. Support your local record stores and add some music to your day from either of the Karma Records Indianapolis locations.

You walk in and its like what you see in the movies. It’s a cd store but they have records as well and it’s a smoke shop! The employees are very knowledgeable and super nice. Definitely check it out!

Best record store , great staff, great selection and great memories, don’t go as much as I’d like but when I do I’m always pleased, thanks for a great experience every visit.

Came into town from Cleveland with family and made a stop here, and WOW. The selection is fantastic, the store is clean and very well organized, and gentleman at the counter was knowledgeable and friendly and checked in on me multiple times. Ended up buying a handful of records and will definitely be back if I am ever in the area again!

This store rocked. Good prices, I found some things I’ve been looking for for years, and the staff is was hella cool.

Awesome place with a great variety of music to choose from. The staff was very friendly and helpful. Definitely worth stopping in if you’re in the area.

Great selection of new and used vinyl and CDs. Also vinyl covers and turntables. Awesome display with vinyl purchases available at the Indiana State Fair.

Amazing experience at an incredible place! First time visiting while traveling and, in five minutes, knew this shop was special. Unique music taste and appreciation merged and owner Andy gifted a hand-written note from a legend. Just the coolest… thanks, Andy! Hope to be back soon!

Indy CD and Vinyl at IN State Fair 2025. Although a sampling of their full retail store stock, has to be the most comprehensive and popular artist selection I’ve seen in decades, including shops near larger metro area such as Atlanta, GA. Many represses in new wrappers. I definitely need to visit their Broad Ripple shop which they said is in close proximity to one of my old vinyl haunts, Praches Records, fortunately they say located there will knowledge of that store’s owner in the day!

I would like to say they sponsored and/or owned the Fair vinyl exhibit memorabilia which was exhilarating and refreshing. The highlight aside from the fair concert that night!

I can’t recommend Indy CD & Vinyl enough. My kiddo and I were visiting the area, and they were so helpful and awesome. They went above and beyond to answer every single question we had, came up to us and offered help, looked stuff up for us, went in the back and found a sticker and a pin for my kid (because they felt bad they didn’t have a particular CD he was looking for), and more. Just truly awesome and friendly. They also offered to ship anything to us that they didn’t have in stock. There was a nice collection of K-Pop albums they were starting too. They even informed us of a new vinyl shop that opened up where we lived (we didn’t even know about it), and then proceeded to look up the name and address for us without even being asked. The atmosphere was great, and you could tell everyone there was knowledgeable and enjoyed what they do. Please stop by and visit them if you’re ever in the area! We’ll definitely be back.

What an awesome shop. Best in Indy. Great owners and they really care about the local music scene. Whenever I wear my Indy CD and Vinyl t-shirt people comment how cool it is. Someone even said that they’ve bought a bunch of records from their Discogs. Amazing record selection and it is always stocked with cool stuff.

Vaughn was great to work with! He bought about half the albums I presented, and he put me in contact with someone who was interested in some vintage stereo equipment. What a great store!

Long time patron. It’s always well organized. I always manage to find exactly what I want. Several years ago I went to a release party with my (then) almost teenager and they gave us a signed poster and were so kind and attentive to them. And now they love to skateboard there. A local business who *truly* cares about the community and their patrons…doesn’t get better than that. Thanks, Annie and all!

They had a great selection and provided really great service. The workers were really helpful and answered all of our questions. We left with a lot of new goodies.

I went in to sell some of my older video games. The place was very busy but even then, they were able to make a quick assessment, utilizing their computer system. The deal was good especially for stuff that has been sitting around for years. Will do business with them again.

I love this place. I go here every Friday evening to browse and pick up a game. Store is always clean, staff is nice, and they always have super cool stuff.

They always have rare and hard to find games. Systems, collectors editions, steel books, etc. NES-modern systems, they have it all. Their switch selections is absolutely massive as well. Easily 200+ titles.

Highly recommend.

If I had to give one criticism, it would be that their prices can be on the higher end. Not crazy high or anything, but they are generally a few dollars more than other places.

Buying dvds is thrilling, I don’t make the rules.

We need to bring back DVD rentals. Subscriptions are insanely expensive, you need like 5-8 different services, and for what? To watch 4 movies a month? Go to your nearest movie store with your pal or date or family. Pick a movie (for $3!!!). Grab snacks. Make it a night. End of story.

My dad and I were looking for a console for my brother’s birthday. We stopped at one store in Castleton Mall and the worker recommended ‘The Exchange’. We walked into a HUGE, clean store with a selection of everything you could need including Nintendo 64s, Wii’s, DS consoles, various system controllers, games, vinyls, posters, etc. We were automatically greeted upon entering before we asked an associate for help. Not only were we given good/relevant information, but an associate physically walked us over to what we were looking for. He explained what all we would need, how the system worked, and was very knowledgeable on the other questions we had. We went up the counter and Blake assisted us. He was very thorough in making sure he explained the exchange policy, how to work the system, and what all came with it. We ended up leaving with a Nintendo 64 console (which came with a controller and cords), 2 games (Donkey Kong 64 and Pokemon Stadium), and an extra controller. Blake got us signed up for rewards (free) and gave us a discount that saved us $50+. The associates were SO knowledgeable (it blew my mind how much these guys knew off the top of their head) and very kind!!! The prices were VERY reasonable and overall we had such an incredible experience. We left the store feeling a HUGE weight lifted off our shoulders because we genuinely had no clue what we needed, but everyone took such great care of us. After my brother’s birthday, we are 100% bringing him back so he can shop around too! You guys are SO awesome and thank you for all your help 🙂 Shoutout Blake!

First time visiting while in town for vacation. Love the way the store is setup. Huge selection of games and more and the staff were all very polite.

Really nice employees and a great selection. Prices are super fair. Folks have a real passion for games. Check it out!

I recently utilized the rental department at Guitar Center for a sound system reservation, and while there were a few hiccups, the exceptional service provided by Ryan and Madison ultimately made for a positive experience.

Upon arrival, there was a bit of a wait, but Ryan, one of the managers, went above and beyond to assist me with my rentals. His professionalism and knowledge were evident as he helped me select the right equipment for my needs.

Unfortunately, one of the stands I rented was broken, which was a bit disappointing. However, I appreciated having brought along an extra pair of stands as backup. While it would have been preferable for the staff to have checked the equipment thoroughly before renting it out, I understand that oversights can happen.

When I returned the rentals, Ryan and Madison were both incredibly helpful and apologetic about the condition of the stand. Their genuine concern and willingness to make things right were greatly appreciated and left a positive impression.

Overall, despite the minor issue with the stand, I was impressed by the level of customer service provided by the rental department at Guitar Center. Ryan and Madison’s professionalism and commitment to customer satisfaction ensured that I would not hesitate to return for future rental needs.

I don’t usually leave reviews, but I had to give some props to this store and especially to Matt. It was pretty busy when I came in, but he was super friendly and welcoming to everyone. Even though he was helping a bunch of people, I never felt ignored or rushed. He helped me find exactly what I needed and made everything quick and easy. I’ve been to a lot of GC stores around the country and worked with several associates, and Matt is hands down one of the best I’ve come across.

Recently stopped at Guitar Center in Castleton to purchase some guitar strings for my son and added yet another great shopping experience there. In addition to excellent customer service, they are making some changes to the guitar wall and it’s looking really nice! Matt, who was both professional and personable, went above and beyond providing a lot of information and answering my many questions. I also spoke with the manager, Alex, who was really helpful too. He even stopped in the middle of something else he was working on to come speak with me. I really appreciate you guys!

I like to kill time by visiting guitar centers or music stores in the areas I’m working. The staff here is great. Mat has helped me a hundred times. He is the king of multitasking and literally has rainbows falling out of his body. Usually the selection of used gear is pretty nice. Just a little short staffed it seems at times so Patience is key. But overall stellar help from the employees.

Matt Erickson provided EXCELLENT CUSTOMER SERVICE! There was a minor delay in receiving some equipment. Once I reached out and brought this to their attention, Matt went above and beyond to make sure that I was taken care of! Thanks again!

My grandson has been taking acoustic guitar lessons here for 2 years. The instructor, Michael is amazing with him. He is patient, kind, and engaging. My grandson is autistic and looks forward to his lessons with Michael

I love your store! I just bought a guitar for my son on last week. You had great service and price was good.
Only thing, you guys hardly ever answer the phone lol. Joking!
Other than that I love your store!

I have gotten Lattes here before and they are pretty good, definitely a good place to get work done. However, this is primarily a record store. They have a good selection and the atmosphere is very cozy. Sometimes they have live events, which is pretty cool. Love the DVD room and listening area.

The guys I was with said the coffee was good. The atmosphere was fun, being inside a vinyl record store where they played cool music.

There’s a stage, and they play live music sometimes.

Great find! Well-laid-out. Even $3 used records were very clean…the 6-8 I checked out. Cool environment… can’t wait to try the coffee in their coffee bar. Also got a good kick out of the two baskets of stickers available for purchase…all refreshingly priced at 99¢ each!!! (The whole $2-$5 for a sticker is just capitalism at its nadir.) Way to go, Square Cat! I look forward to returning.

The hubs and I came here for record store day. Embarrassingly, it was our first time visiting. The place is adorable! We didn’t end up trying the coffee, but it smelled amazing! I also found one of my faves at a great price!

Great spot to sip on a coffee and hangout in the listening booths and explore their used vinyls!

-EspressoTech Service Co.

Pretty cool place, they had a live stage(nothing playing when I went, but still cool). They also had a very unique sorting system, with stuff like Indianapolis locals and by genre and alphabetical. The arcade they flak about is 2 half cab arcade cabinets. Cassette and CD selection is limited, definitely a vinyl shop as they are named.

Awesome experience! Love that you can listen to open records while there. Staff was helpful. Beer or coffee while you browze?? Yes, please!!

Come here often for their album release listening parties. They always have a good selection and I have to kept control of myself, because a lot of money would be spent. All the employees I’ve meet have been super awesome and helpful. They’ll even order vinyls in for you if they’re out of stock. Plus, I love that they are a community forward business.

Went here for the first time on record store day. I found a LOT of great albums, for decent prices! I can’t wait to go back and do some more digging!

This shop has a great vibe. So much great music, cute merchandise, and great customer service. The records I purchased there were in excellent condition and fairly priced. Highly recommended!

Always a fun time! We went to 2 record stores the same day before hitting up Luna. Luna had all 3 albums we were looking for. Family tradition through generations at this point.

I have been to record stores all over the United States and beyond at this point (Chicago, Seattle, Vancouver, etc). I have yet to find a record store with more knowledgeable and lovely staff (shout out to Josh and Alex who are always willing to listen to me ramble about wrestling, or MTG, whatever british indie nonsense I am looking for), incredible selection of a wide amount of genres and musical eras, and genuine love for the medium and music in general than Luna. Seriously, everywhere I go, every other record store I go into, I wish I were back at Luna, and you will too once you spend time here. Luna ->

Solid selection. A must visit for anyone who loves music and needs more vinyl in their life.

Great record store. Staff is always friendly and helpful. Everytime I’ve come in looking for something specific they have helped me find it or if they don’t have it they have ordered it for me if they could.

When I was being checked out at the store i was tricked into signing up for a paid monthly subscription membership while being under the impression that I was simply giving them an email and phone number just to receive 10% off. many other stores ask for this to simply send you promotional emails, give you a one time discount, or make returning something to the store easier. I was not told I would be signing myself up for this paid subscription. Do not give them any of your information as it signs you up to pay them $13 a month and they save your debit or credit card information for this. Upon further research on this they make it very hard to cancel this membership and many people have reported this company to the FTC for this. Not okay.

Really cool place. This is the kind of store that would be hard to find anywhere other than Chicago, so I thought it was awesome to see it here. A large selection of stuff, organized store, and nice staff!

It’s ok. Need to do away with membership. Employees pressure customers. Even when they say no, thank you. They still try to get you to sign up. So sad!! They did it to me 1x time before. Know I have to call and cancel again. They automatically take cash out of your accounts. Every month of around 11 dollars. Not good business. Employees miss telling me 2x times. My boyfriend reminded me that I did sign up for it 1x before. I cancle it due to this problem. I didn’t receive anything through mail from them. Explain this, nor did they say nothing about it coming out of account. What ever card you use. They take from that account.

Nice stuff, unfortunately the store is so messy. The unfolded shirts and thrown around product is overwhelming. Also got a stink eye from an associate cause I only bought a redbull. She also scoffed at me

The store itself has a lot of cool stuff, but it’s really overpriced, especially the Asian snacks. You can get them for half the price at any Asian market in town.

When I checked out, the sales associate signed me up for their membership program which I assumed was free, and didn’t realize was $12 a month until he tried to get me to sign an agreement on the credit machine. He talked about the whole thing like it was free and never once mentioned a cost or a free trial until I asked when I saw a charge on the agreement.

I know sales associates get credit for signing people up for email and the store rewards and things like that, so I always do it if it’s free and unsubscribe later, but I’ve never had someone so purposely misrepresent a paid subscription. It was very predatory and I know a cost would not have been mentioned if I had not asked.

At that point, I had been at this register way too long for my small purchase, so I agreed after he showed me how easy it was to cancel online. But then when I went to cancel online, there was a persistent error and I had to call in. And when I called in, the customer service associate gave me a whole long sales pitch and then says “So I’ll keep your membership active.” No! She finally canceled but I wouldn’t be shocked if I still get charged. Their whole VIP program is super predatory and difficult to cancel. If you choose to shop here, do not sign up for anything.

A nice store with a little bit of all pop culture. Some music, some movies, anime merch, pop figurines, albums, etc.

so loves this store! video fanatic that he is,spends at least an hour each visit

Tommy Wills was extremely helpful with getting repairs made to our alto sax. He also recommended accessories that my daughter will need as a beginner. Great experience. Conveniently located downtown.

The staff are always nice and very helpful. The instrument rental process is easy. We did everything over the phone. I was unsure if I would be approved to rent an instrument because of my credit, but Musicians Repair and Sales approved me! They will work with you to get your student an instrument. Highly recommended.

My family has been renting/buying/repairing from Dan and his team for two years. They have always been so flexible, accommodating, and knowledgeable. This week, they stepped up big time with a last minute rescue on a sizing error of mine with my kid’s cello. The communication from them has always been excellent. My impression is that they are committed to instilling an appreciation for music in young people. I love the community feel here and look forward to many more years of working with them.

musicians Repair is wonderful. They do great work, they are friendly, and they always come in ahead of schedule.

Great little place right in downtown Indy.If you need a repair or just some info this is a great place to come.Very nice friendly folks.You can buy strings or many different things,come check them out!

Had my 66 year old flute completely refurbished! They did an excellent job. Looks almost new! Highly recommend their services.

Ryker did a fantastic job repairing my Dad’s 1950s banjo-uke. I could not be more pleased! Great place where everyone should shop or have their instruments repaired!

Been to Arthur’s a number of times with my husband. I always appreciated the bench right inside the door when I could sit and read or crochet.

This time, however, I was the customer looking to purchase my first ukulele. Emily took all the time in the world with me, answering my 300 questions. I could not have dreamed up a better experience. Thank you!

Worked with Steve on a vintage guitar they had on consignment. We didn’t end up being able to make the numbers work but I have before in the past. His customer service was so high throughout the extended I wanted to write a review here just for the assistance. Thanks Steve and team!

Oh, the delightful older lady with the short hair who I suppose is the owner, was just a joy to encounter. Such a shining example of kindness and hospitality. I simply can’t wait to go back and experience her charming personality all over again. Just kidding she is awful and wont be back again she needs to get a new Attitude/ Personality! Just Horrible! If you don’t like what you do, don’t do it you ain’t gotta be hateful to everybody else wont be back ever again! Try Smiling I’m not being such a Karen

How did I not know about this place? They have a very wide range of stringed instruments. I found a mandola, a bouzouki, a selection of dulcimer, and a bunch of other cool stuff. They also stock instruments at a range of prices. If you are on a budget, you’ll have lots of options.

The staff is friendly and knowledgeable. I brought in a guitar I made, just to see what they thought. They gave me some good comments and really spent time with me. I was also looking at mandolins. The lady I talked with was most helpful.

I’m definitely coming back. If you like stringed instruments, check this place out.

Great music store in Indy. I love that is local and has been in Fountain Square a long time. Highly recommend for those who play stringed instruments!

Everytime I go to Arthur’s, they make me feel like family. They truly care about my needs and take the time to cater their approach to me individually. I’m a low $ customer, but they always treat me like I’m their #1.
Simply the best!

Lots of guitars and stringed instruments. Also sells harmonicas, including cheap ones.

Great vibe here! Guitar Center didn’t have what we needed. Turns out this is the spot. Great gear selection — all the standards + some really cool bespoke stuff. Staff were friendly & offered great customer service. This store is legit. Never going back to GC!!

I love going in here. They are always so nice and clean and they had a really rare find last time I went which I made a good trade for my boyfriend’s birthday surprise. I have been looking for this specific guitar for years and finally found it here. They also went out of their way to make sure I got everything I needed to go alone with the instrument to ensure he could try out my gift right away without needing to make any extra trips. Thanks for all the great help.

Flew down from New England on business and needed a tuner on the spot. Paul Beeman was knowledgeable and answered all my questions. The songs I was working on were tuned weird and I brought the wrong tuner with me. I told him I didn’t want to break the bank and that I had what I needed back home. He took the time and dug around a bit and found me a used On-Stage GTP7000. He even helped out on an open box power adapter for it. There was no pushy salesman upselling. He even demo’d it for me.
Great experience all around. Tons of stuff there new and gently used.
I highly recommend this location if you’re in the area for all your music needs.
Thanks again Paul for all the help.
Good Luck!

Staff was friendly, but I gave them my number twice about a certain used bass and I was never called even after a reminder after the first no-call. They also close a lot for seemingly minor reasons, so I’ve had trouble planning on the store being open. Still, a good selection of used gear so it’s a nice place to browse.

This is the review you’re looking for if you’re curious

1. Should I get my important instrument repaired here? YES
2. Could they have the gear I want but used at a better value? YES
3. Is the little thing I need TODAY actually in stock? YES

A few weeks ago, I had to drop off my banjo that was poorly repaired by a downtown shop. I was a professional touring guitar player for 10 years on the road so I have unfairly high expectations. When Paul checked in my dobro and banjo I was floored that he made sure EVERY SINGLE DETAIL was accurate.

Insane variety of electric guitars, amps and drums. Most pedals in Indy at best prices. Even if you’re a deal digger??? I literally found the exact $50 dobro slide I’d almost bought used for about $15 ‍♂️

If you’re coming around the corner in Castleton to go to GC. You should be going here first, zero question.

This store does light my music life up. I originally bought a ibanez destroyer and Paul made my day. Be cool and come on in you will get treated right. I just keep coming back. Set ups are incredible great services.

They fixed my scratchy pot on my fender rumble 25 in like 2 seconds it was amazing!! I have sold things and bought things here a couple times. Always a great experience!!