Best bakeries in Indianapolis: find options near you
Indianapolis boasts a rich culinary scene, and among its treasures are some truly remarkable artisan bakeries that cater to the sweet tooth and craving for freshly baked goods. From classic treats to innovative pastries, these establishments have become beloved spots, drawing in locals and visitors alike for their delectable offerings. Each bakery showcases a unique philosophy and approach to baking, reflecting the creativity and talent of their skilled artisans.
The city’s selection of baking establishments highlights a blend of tradition and modernity, providing everything from fresh bread and intricate cakes to mouthwatering cookies and pastries. With an emphasis on quality ingredients and heartfelt craftsmanship, these top-rated spots have earned remarkable reputations. Patrons can expect not only delightful flavors but also a warm, inviting atmosphere that enhances the experience of enjoying freshly made delights.
1. Long’s Bakery
Tuesday: 05:30–22:00
Wednesday: 05:30–22:00
Thursday: 05:30–22:00
Friday: 05:30–22:00
Saturday: 05:30–22:00
Sunday: 05:30–22:00
Long’s Bakery offers an exceptional array of **delicious** pastries that never fail to impress. Known for their **classic** recipes, each bite is a delightful experience that leaves customers wanting more. The atmosphere may be bustling, but the service remains efficient and friendly, making the wait worthwhile.
Their **artisan donuts** are a particular highlight, with a variety of flavors perfect for any sweet tooth. Prices are reasonable, especially considering the quality of the treats. Long’s Bakery is a must-visit spot for anyone seeking a taste of **nostalgic** bakery delights.
Cash only. Be prepared
2. Crumbl – Keystone Shoppes
Tuesday: 08:00–18:00
Wednesday: Closed
Thursday: 08:00–22:00
Friday: 08:00–22:00
Saturday: 08:00–22:00
Sunday: Closed
Crumbl – Keystone Shoppes offers a delightful experience for cookie lovers. The ambiance is cozy and inviting, creating the perfect atmosphere for indulging in their unique cookie creations. Each cookie is a large, decadent treat that is sure to satisfy any sweet tooth, making it a great option for dessert.
Moreover, the customer service is commendable, with staff who are friendly and knowledgeable about the various flavors. It’s exciting to see new offerings each week, making every visit a fresh adventure. Overall, Crumbl stands out not only for its exceptional cookies but also for its welcoming approach to customer service.
My cousins and I came by for dessert after dinner right before closing on a weekday. Our flavors: oreo cheesecake, chocolate chip, strawberry, and fruit tart.
We got a 4 cookie box. I thought it was pricey until I saw the size of the cookies—they’re huge! It’s like $5 dollars per cookie after tax and tip. We don’t have sweet tooth’s so we each shared a bite. I recommend having this with milk to wash down the sugar. The idea of a 800-1000 calorie cookie scares me but I would have a hard time finishing just one, let alone a whole box on my own.
The strawberry cookie had a sweet strawberry icing that tasted like real strawberries! Didn’t taste artificial; not tart and had added sweetness from the sugar but this was the highlight for me. The cookie was a sugar cookie base.
The red white and blue (?): Another sugar cookie base, this was a pretty cookie but quite sweet. Nothing to write home about.
The chocolate chips in the cookie were caramel-colored and a bit big so it doesn’t look like a traditional chocolate chip cookie. It was my favorite out of the four. The chips are too sweet for me so I like the dough more.
The oreo cheesecake looked the heaviest so we saved it for last, but surprisingly it was the least sweet! The cheese flavor balances the sugar out. There’s a nice crust on the bottom too.
Honestly didn’t feel that great after eating this for dessert but it was a novel experience getting to see all the flavors and pretty cookies.
The cookie was delicious on a scale of 1 to 10. I would give it a solid 7.2, not the very best, but also above average. It was soft but not too soft; it had a good cookie ratio to chocolate chips. I think I would have enjoyed the cookie a bit more if it were a bit crispier but not crunchy if that makes sense. Is the cookie worth 5$ a cookie ? Humm probably considering how expensive ingredients are these days, so for the price point, it’s worth it. Is it as good as Nothing Bundt cakes? While it’s like comparing apples to oranges, it is a niche pastry business, and so on that level, yes.
3. Heidelberg Haus
Tuesday: 08:30–19:00
Wednesday: 08:30–19:00
Thursday: 08:30–19:00
Friday: 08:30–19:00
Saturday: 08:30–17:00
Sunday: 11:00–17:00
Heidelberg Haus is a delightful mix of German culture and culinary excellence. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it an ideal spot for a casual meal or a special occasion. The food is incredibly satisfying, showcasing a variety of traditional dishes that resonate with authenticity and flavor.
The service is commendable, with staff who exhibit a genuine passion for their craft. Every dish served is a testament to their commitment to quality, ensuring an enjoyable experience for all visitors. This unique café offers a wonderful getaway to indulge in delicious pastries and hearty meals, leaving patrons eager to return.
4. Gallery Pastry Shop
Tuesday: 09:00–21:00
Wednesday: 09:00–16:00
Thursday: 09:00–21:00
Friday: 09:00–22:00
Saturday: 09:00–22:00
Sunday: 09:00–16:00
The Gallery Pastry Shop offers a charming atmosphere combined with a creative culinary experience. Customers rave about the delightful selection of pastries and the innovative twists on classic dishes, making it a perfect spot for brunch. The attentive staff enhances the dining experience, ensuring you feel valued and well-cared for throughout your visit.
Whether you’re indulging in their signature croissants or enjoying a unique savory creation, each dish is meticulously crafted with fresh ingredients. The inviting decor and friendly service make the Gallery Pastry Shop a must-visit for anyone seeking comfort food that doesn’t compromise on flavor or artistry.
The Bougie Benedict was a breath of fresh air compared to your normal Eggs Benedict. The dish had perfectly cooked eggs, crispy bacon, and a touch of caviar on top all sitting on the fluff croissant. The burst of flavors tingle your taste buds with every bite.
The BLT croissant sandwich I had was impressive, with a buttery, flaky exterior surrounding fresh greens, savory bacon, and tomato provided a well-balanced mix of textures.
The fries were another standout — crisp, perfectly seasoned, and garnished with herbs, making each bite satisfying. Accompanied by 3 sauces, Pesto Mayo, Homemade Hot Sauce and Green Goddess Sauce, it felt like a comforting yet elevated take on a classic side dish.
Overall, the shop exudes a charming ambiance with thoughtful touches, like the small decorative pumpkin, adding a seasonal flair. It’s an excellent spot for indulging in both comfort food and culinary artistry. Highly recommended for brunch lovers and anyone with a taste for fresh, innovative pastry creations.
The only downside was they were sold out of the Taylor Swift Macaroons!
The croissant is so flaky and buttery. I’d reccomend getting something other then the gravy and croissant.
When I ordered it I did not know I was getting mostly gravy. It was AWESOME. I just wasn’t feeling it that day! Most people arnt about this much gravy. I ended up taking it with me for eating onto of my husband’s leftovers.
5. Taylor’s Bakery
Tuesday: 07:00–17:00
Wednesday: Closed
Thursday: Closed
Friday: 07:00–17:00
Saturday: 07:00–17:00
Sunday: Closed
Taylor’s Bakery offers an exceptional variety of baked goods, making it a favorite among locals. The online ordering system is user-friendly, and customers appreciate the prompt and efficient service they receive. Plus, the aesthetic appeal of their cakes and pastries is just as delightful as their taste.
The quality of the treats is outstanding, with flavors that are both rich and well-balanced. Many patrons rave about the moistness of the cakes and the creativity in their designs. Overall, Taylor’s Bakery stands out for its commitment to excellence and customer satisfaction.
Update:
The cakes were amazing. They tasted great, weren’t dry at all and they looked great. The lavender icing could’ve been mixed a bit more, but besides that they were great and everyone loved them.
And this was my first time buying it here and I was in a crunch for time! Let me tell you if this wasn’t (I’m not making this up) one the best cakes we’ve ever had! We mean it. The cake was so moist and the flavor is astounding but not overpowering. It was sweet but easy on the stomach and light and the cream just flowed and it’s been consistently tasting the same as the first bite as we’ve been eating at it for the last couple of days.
The wife has been talking about the cake with everyone from how beautiful it looked to the taste. Definitely 1000x better than getting cheap cakes from non bakeries. And the experience from start to finish online to picking up in the bakery was flawless experience. We are incredibly happy with the purchase, the experience, and of course the taste (and even how affordable it was for the quality we got!)
6. Sweet Escape Cake Company
Tuesday: Closed
Wednesday: Closed
Thursday: 09:00–18:00
Friday: 09:00–18:00
Saturday: 09:00–14:00
Sunday: Closed
Sweet Escape Cake Company truly stands out with their exceptional baking skills and attention to detail. From customized cakes to delightful cookies, they consistently deliver visually stunning creations that taste as good as they look. Customers rave about the quality and flavor of their products, making every celebration memorable.
Their professionalism and efficient service set them apart in the event catering industry. With timely responses and an eagerness to accommodate special requests, Sweet Escape Cake Company ensures a pleasant experience from order to delivery, making them a top choice for any special occasion.
Very pleased! I referred to them everyone at the party. Will definitely be using again!
My daughter’s 16th birthday party was the best we ever had! She was so proud of her cake!
Thank you so much. I already made plans for next year’s party and added a reminder on my phone so I can order ahead of time.
7. Pana Donuts
Tuesday: 05:00–18:00
Wednesday: 05:00–18:00
Thursday: 05:00–18:00
Friday: 05:00–18:00
Saturday: 05:00–18:00
Sunday: 05:00–18:00
Pana Donuts offers an amazing selection of fresh and tasty donuts that are perfect for any time of the day. The atmosphere is clean and welcoming, making it a great spot for families and friends to gather over delicious treats. Additionally, their friendly staff ensure a pleasant experience, whether dining in or using their efficient drive-through service.
Not only are the donuts incredibly soft and flavorful, but Pana also offers delightful alternatives like croissant sandwiches and drinks. The consistent quality of their offerings and the attentiveness of the staff make Pana a beloved spot for those looking to indulge in something sweet and satisfying. It’s a fantastic addition to the local food scene!
8. The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers
Tuesday: 11:00–19:00
Wednesday: 11:00–19:00
Thursday: 11:00–19:00
Friday: 10:00–21:00
Saturday: 10:00–21:00
Sunday: 10:00–19:00
The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers offers a truly enchanting experience, blending an exquisite atmosphere with delightful food. From the moment you step inside, the charming décor and warm ambiance create a sense of joy that complements their delectable offerings, making it a perfect spot for gatherings with family and friends.
The service is equally impressive, with staff members who are attentive and genuinely care about your dining experience. Whether you’re celebrating a special event or simply indulging in a sweet treat, the personal touch and friendly service ensure that every visit feels memorable. It’s a delightful destination that leaves a lasting impression!
The menu has lots to choose from and the food I ordered was very good! The bread and butter they bring out before the meal is literally to die for! I ordered the turkey & gruyere sandwich with the arugula salad and a cup of the chicken velvet soup, all were delicious, but the soup was definitely the show stopper! So yummy!!
I’ve always heard mixed reviews about their cakes, so I decided to stick with a cake that I love and that was the carrot cake. First off, the glitter on the cake, so cute, just love it!! The cake itself was moist and it was good cake, the icing and the filling were good as well, but it’s not your typical icing or filling, it’s more of a muted flavor, but I think it compliments the cake well and I would definitely order it again.
The service was fine, I didn’t feel they went over and above or that the service was exceptional, but certainly no complaints or issues.
The only issue I had was the wait and the space. We had reservations, arrived about 10 minutes early and still had a 30 minute wait and while I do appreciate they don’t rush their customers, I think that 30 minutes is too long of a wait when you have made reservations. Also, for anyone that may be claustrophobic, it’s pretty full when all tables are at capacity. Granted, I think the size of the restaurant adds to the allure of the place, but if you’re seated in the front of the restaurant, there is not a lot of room. Despite those two issues, I’d return, it’s just too cute not to!!
9. Boyden’s Southside Bakery
Tuesday: 05:00–19:00
Wednesday: 05:00–19:00
Thursday: 05:00–19:00
Friday: 05:00–19:00
Saturday: 05:00–17:00
Sunday: Closed
Boyden’s Southside Bakery offers a delightful range of baked goods that never fail to impress. Their cookies are not only tasty but also beautifully decorated, making them perfect for any occasion. The selection of specialty items, including custom cakes, is a treat that locals cherish.
Customers rave about the quality and freshness of their products, often returning for more. Each visit to Boyden’s promises delicious moments, whether it’s celebrating a special event or simply indulging in a sweet treat. This bakery truly exemplifies the essence of community and taste.
I do not eat this, too much sugar too sweet for me.
10. Kolache Factory
Tuesday: 06:00–14:00
Wednesday: 06:00–14:00
Thursday: 06:00–14:00
Friday: 06:00–14:00
Saturday: 06:00–14:00
Sunday: 07:00–14:00
Kolache Factory is a delightful spot offering an impressive array of tasty pastries, known for their soft dough and diverse fillings. Each visit promises a unique experience, whether you opt for classic breakfast options or innovative flavors. The quality and freshness of the food truly stand out, making it a delightful choice for any meal of the day.
The exceptional service provided by the friendly staff adds to the overall experience, ensuring customers feel welcomed and valued. A perfect stop for anyone craving delicious food at reasonable prices, Kolache Factory is definitely a recommendation for breakfast or lunch lovers looking for something special.
Definitely will return and highly recommend making this restaurant that has been here 20 years a stop for great Kolache!
How to find your ideal bakery at the best price in Indianapolis?
Request help now to find the best price:
- Fill in the details and tell us what you're looking for
- We locate the best bakery in Indianapolis near you
- The company contacts you
Catalog of services offered by bakeries in Indianapolis
Custom Cake Design
Many bakeries in Indianapolis specialize in custom cake design. This service allows customers to create unique cakes for various occasions such as weddings, birthdays, and anniversaries. Bakers work closely with clients to incorporate specific themes, flavors, and decorations, ensuring that each cake is a personal reflection of the event.
Fresh Bread and Pastries
Freshly baked bread and pastries are a staple in Indianapolis bakeries. From artisan loafs to flaky croissants, these establishments offer a wide variety of baked goods made from high-quality ingredients. Customers can enjoy the aroma of bread baking and the delightful textures of pastries that are perfect for breakfast or an afternoon treat.
Specialty Desserts
Bakeries often provide an array of specialty desserts to cater to diverse palates. This may include items like cheesecakes, tarts, cookies, and brownies, made with unique flavors and high-quality ingredients. Many bakeries also accommodate dietary restrictions, offering gluten-free, vegan, or sugar-free options.
Catering Services
For events and gatherings, bakeries in Indianapolis frequently offer catering services. This service typically includes a selection of baked goods, desserts, and sometimes savory items suitable for parties, corporate events, and celebrations. Bakeries often work with clients to design the perfect menu that fits the theme of the event.
Seasonal and Holiday Treats
Throughout the year, bakeries create seasonal and holiday treats to celebrate various occasions. This could include pumpkin-flavored goods in the fall, festive cookies during the winter holidays, or themed pastries for local festivals. These offerings allow customers to enjoy traditional flavors associated with specific times of the year.
Bakery Classes and Workshops
Some bakeries also offer bakery classes and workshops, providing an opportunity for individuals to learn the art of baking from experienced professionals. Participants can take courses on topics such as bread-making, cake decorating, and pastry techniques, often resulting in a fun and informative experience for both beginners and seasoned bakers.
Online Ordering and Delivery
In today’s digital world, many bakeries have embraced online ordering and delivery services. This allows customers to conveniently browse menus, place orders, and have their favorite baked goods delivered right to their doorstep. This service has become increasingly popular, especially for those who prefer to enjoy their treats from home.
Collaboration with Local Farmers
Many bakeries are committed to supporting local communities by sourcing ingredients from nearby farms. This collaboration with local farmers not only ensures the freshness of the products but also supports sustainability and local economies. Customers can often find seasonal ingredients that highlight the best of what Indianapolis has to offer.
Frequently asked questions about bakeries in Indianapolis
What types of baked goods are commonly found in bakeries in Indianapolis?
Bakeries in Indianapolis offer a wide variety of baked goods, including artisan bread, pastries, cookies, cakes, and pies. Many bakeries also specialize in custom orders for special occasions like birthdays and weddings. Additionally, some provide gluten-free or vegan options to cater to diverse dietary preferences.
How do I choose a bakery in Indianapolis?
Choosing a bakery can be based on several factors, including location, product variety, and customer reviews. It’s advisable to explore social media and online platforms to find popular bakeries. Visiting a few bakeries to sample their items can also help you determine which one aligns best with your taste and needs.
Are bakeries in Indianapolis open on weekends?
Many bakeries in Indianapolis operate on weekends, often with special hours or limited menu offerings. However, it’s important to check individual bakery schedules as they can vary. Some may even feature freshly baked goods that are exclusive to the weekend, making it a great time to visit.
Do bakeries offer custom cake services?
Yes, most bakeries in Indianapolis offer custom cake services for special events. Customers can typically discuss their design preferences, flavors, and sizes with the bakery staff to create a unique cake. Providing adequate notice and details about the event can help ensure that your custom cake exceeds expectations.
What is the average price range for baked goods in Indianapolis bakeries?
The price of baked goods can vary widely depending on the type of item, size, and complexity of the order. On average, cookies may range from $1 to $3 each, while cakes might start at $25 for basic options and increase with customization. It is advisable to inquire directly with the bakery for specific pricing.
Are there any bakeries that specialize in vegan or gluten-free options?
Yes, several bakeries in Indianapolis cater to customers seeking vegan and gluten-free products. These establishments often use alternatives to traditional ingredients to create baked goods that align with specific dietary needs. Checking their menus online or calling ahead can provide information on their offerings.
Do Indianapolis bakeries provide delivery services?
Many bakeries in Indianapolis offer delivery services or partner with delivery platforms to ensure that customers can easily receive their orders at home. Delivery availability may depend on the bakery's location, order size, and specific arrangements, so it's advisable to confirm these details beforehand.
Can I place bulk orders for events at bakeries?
Bakeries in Indianapolis often accommodate bulk orders for events such as parties, weddings, and corporate functions. When placing a large order, it’s recommended to provide as much advance notice as possible and to discuss your exact needs, including item types and quantities, with the bakery staff.
What are some popular bakeries to try in Indianapolis?
Some highly regarded bakeries in Indianapolis include La Mie Emilie, known for its artisan breads, Taylor's Bakery, famous for cakes and pastries, and The Cake Bake Shop, celebrated for its beautifully decorated cakes. Exploring local reviews and social media can also lead you to hidden gems in the area.
What should I know about the bakery's ingredients?
Many bakeries pride themselves on using high-quality, fresh ingredients. Customers can inquire about the source of ingredients and whether they comply with specific dietary restrictions. Bakeries often provide a list of ingredient information for their products, especially for those with common allergens like nuts or dairy.