All Star Tire & Auto Service

Had a flat tire and wasted a day at a big-name shop downtown — they promised same-day service twice and didn’t deliver, then quoted me $500 for a replacement I didn’t need. Called All Star Tire and Auto Services on N Capitol Ave and had the BEST experience — they fixed my tire in under an hour for just $37. Friendly, honest, and fast! If you work downtown, skip the chains and go to this locally owned, family-run shop. Highly recommend!

We popped a tire during our road trip and this place was a lifesaver! Got us in quickly and had us back on the road in no time. The staff were super helpful and efficient, and made our situation less stressful. We’re so grateful for their fast and friendly service!

Chris and his team are incredibly professional, efficient, and fair. I brought my Civic in for new brakes and a mysterious issue with my battery/starter, and they did everything possible to diagnose the cause. They updated me regularly on their progress and always told me about the tests they ran and all the different ways to assess the cause. They followed up after my car was returned. I highly recommend All Star for any automotive issues. These guys are the best.

I went in because I needed a axel replacement (of course I didn’t know that at the moment) so I paid 160 for a diagnostic test and test drive. He did the test, told me he’d figure the problem out and fix it. Fast forward they called back and told me they knew the problem.. They said I needed a wheel alignment and new tires. Me not knowing much I believed them.He told me it sounded as good as new so I picked my car up and as soon as I left the lot the sound started up again. I went back he told me to come back in am to test drive it. He heard the sound then said " wow that’s shocking we test drove it nine times me and other employees, we even took it to a lot to do a few circles" It’s no way he could have without hearing the sound because the problem was never fixed.. I left my car again, called back maybe a hour later to check on it and he said he couldn’t figure out the problem and I need to go somewhere else to get it looked at and he’ll refund me 90 dollars for the diagnostic test. I then asked well can I have a little more because I was charged 630 dollars in total for the service including the oil change, wheel alignment, and 2 tires. He also told me I was paying for the problem to be fixed but it wasn’t fixed. Not to mention I got another diagnostic test for free somewhere else and a few other issues popped up that he failed to mention. I still wanted to be reasonable so explained to him that I paid for the problem to be fixed and felt like it didn’t get fixed. He got an attitude with me told me to pick up my car claimed they’d been open for years and that I should’ve taken it to Nissan from the jump. I then asked why didn’t he say that when he knew he didn’t know what the problem was? He hung up.. Overall I wouldn’t go here they charge you for stuff and don't find the real problems in your car they’ll just find any reason to charge you.. I wouldn’t come here if you don’t know what the problem is because i took it to a mechanic and he instantly knew the problem and fixed it… If you know nothing about cars DON’T COME they will talk you into all type of things to add on the the problem and they might not even solve the real problem like he did me. I’ve also notice a lot of the owners replies are fake a lot of stuff he was saying sounded like it’s tweaked to sound better. Edit: I was only refunded 90 dollars I didn’t ask for a full refund just more than what I was given based off the fact that the noise I came in for was not fixed. I didn’t say it sounded like the front end tire I said it’s a noise under the car and could be the tires but as you know I’m no mechanic so I wouldn’t know what it is hence to why I paid for a diagnostic test. You all lied and pretended you never heard a noise after "fixing the problem" when truthfully that’s impossible if the problem was never fixed. I agreed to fixing the noise not the tires or alignment no paper work was signed for you to do any of those things though, I did not agree to that.

Blew a tire on I-70 on my way to work. Called them as soon as they opened and asked about new tires and availability. They got me in same day, replaced all four of my tires, gave me an alignment, then did an oil change, all for several hundred dollars left than I would have paid for in my own city. They even guaranteed I’d get my car back by a certain time and had it waiting for me when I got there. The staff was extremely friendly and answered any questions I had. Wonderful family-owned company that’s maintaining themselves in a corporate-owned market.

Very nice and friendly customer service. However I called and requested a specific tire. Chris advised me against the tires I requested which are also the ones that come On my vehicle. The price was $600.00 more than what I asked for which were the manufacturer installed tires. I was referred but this wasn’t the type of referral that was helpful. I was able to source the tires and have them installed and was under 1000. I was quoted 1690. I saw the comments from this establishment and how tone deaf and arrogant they sound. The tires I requested were the ones that were on the vehicle new purchased from the manufacturer, which is why I wanted those tire specifically! I did not ask Nor did I want an increase in quality, cost, nor did I ask for an opinion about what they thought would be best for Indiana in the winter. Consequently, I’m not an Indiana resident. Like I said I did not ask for that information so it’s pretty smug of a response by this company. The prospective customer asked for something certain and that request was to give the price of the four tires. So in short tires that cost me $1000 they want to put on for 1700 (but an upgrade, don’t even know why we didn’t get price in the ones I requested. ) And end up with a $2200 bid. Feels kind of scammy to me!

My daughter was in Indy and damaged a tire. Called and Chris was able to get her in immediately. Great communication, reasonably priced and was just an easy transaction. Thanks again Chris for getting her back on the road!