Shapiro's Delicatessen

Shapiro's Deli is a great example of a classic, cafeteria-style deli done right. From the moment you step in, you're met with a wide array of food choices hot entrees, sandwiches, soups, salads, sides, and a tempting selection of desserts. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty Reuben, a bowl of matzo ball soup, or just a slice of pie and coffee, there's something here for everyone. The food is consistently good and made with obvious care. The meats are flavorful and fresh, the portions are generous, and the sides feel like something out of a well loved family recipe book. It’s a place that values tradition, and it shows in the quality of their dishes. Prices are on the higher end for a deli, which might catch you off guard if you’re expecting a budget-friendly quick bite. That said, you do get what you pay for good food, quick service, and a clean, well maintained dining area. One of the biggest strengths of Shapiro's is its versatility for group dining. If you're going out with a group of people who all have different preferences or dietary needs, this is a solid choice. With so many options, it's hard not to find something that hits the spot. All in all, Shapiro's is a dependable and satisfying stop in Indy, especially if you're craving classic deli fare with a touch of comfort and quality.

Sadly I think this is my last visit. I’ve been coming to Shapiro’s for 11 years. I used to hold it in the highest regard for quality. The sandwiches used to be absolutely out of this world, some of the best I’ve ever had. Unfortunately for the past 4 years the prices have continually gone up and the quality has gone down. I don’t typically write reviews but I felt compelled to. The last several times I’ve come here the meat on the sandwiches was just not like it used to be. $22.50 for a pastrami sandwich that more than half of the meat is grisly fat. $4.50 for a deviled egg. The deviled eggs are still delicious, but people come for the sandwiches not the sides. I understand prices have gone up and I’m okay paying more if I can still get the same quality. But it is not. Hopefully they can make changes and get back to what people have loved for decades. But until then, I don’t think I’ll be spending any more money here.

I only rated it as 5* because there is no higher number available. The 5* for atmosphere is based on the genre. I didn't think there would be a Jewish deli this good in the Midwest, but I was wrong. The corned beef, pastrami, matzoh balls, chopped liver and cheesecake were really excellent and enough for two meals... No scrimping on portions. No fatty meat. Thick hand sliced homemade rye bread was perfect. A nice full menu. It is cafeteria style to get your food but the line moves quickly and the sandwiches are made to order while you watch. And plenty of free parking despite the fact it's downtown in a large city. I will definitely be back the next time I'm in Indy!

It has been years since our last visit to Shapiro's Deli. But we stopped in after a flight from Florida, and headed to Fort Wayne. The great: The cafeteria style environment has remained true and authentic for as long as I have visited. The meat-loaf was good and tasty with no complaints. The just ok: The mac-n-cheese had some very hard to chew, very crunchy like hard candy on parts on top, but maybe that was a style. The not so great: This time, and the last time we visited Shapiro's, the crust/corners/edges of my Rye bread were rock hard and very tough to eat...so hard that I had to remove it from the Corned Beef and Pastrami sandwich....not ideal when considering that the crust is a big part of the experience. Was it old bread? Over baked? I don't know, but not a good experience. Last, as just an observation or maybe a point for extra employee training: some customers do not know the "Shapiro way" of ordering and navigating the system. Train your employees behind the glass cases to be patient with those who came to spend their money at your establishment. For the amount of money spent on lunch, I just expected a more superb experience and product.

This place absolutely lives up to the hype. Best Reuben in the state of Indiana? No. Best Reuben in the entire country. No comparison. Everything taste fresh. Service is friendly and speedy. Absolutely will dine here again.

Classic Jewish deli experience. Outstanding in every regard. You will almost always see someone, though you may not know, that is noteworthy in this community. For example, today I saw a former congressman. I’ve noticed a few reviews concerning pricing. However, given that prices have in fact gone up over the last several years, this still represent an excellent value. Folks, you spend $10-$15 at Subway, you’re gonna spend more for this. It’s damn worth it.

If you’re looking for an authentic deli experience with top-quality food, look no further than Shapiro’s Delicatessen! I stopped in for a classic corned beef sandwich, and it was absolutely outstanding. The corned beef was perfectly seasoned, tender, and piled high on fresh, flavorful rye bread. Each bite had just the right balance of savory richness and melt-in-your-mouth texture. The sandwich was served warm, with just enough juiciness to make it incredibly satisfying without being overly greasy. Beyond the food, the service was friendly and efficient. The staff made sure everything was just right and kept the atmosphere welcoming. The deli itself has a nostalgic charm that adds to the experience—you can tell they’ve been serving quality meals for years. If you appreciate a great corned beef sandwich (or any deli classic), Shapiro’s is a must-visit. I’ll definitely be coming back!