Play It Again Sports

07/15/2025 We called to ask if they had size 13 rollerblades in stock and the gentleman on the phone said yes, so next day we drove to the store. While trying on that pair, they said they had another pair just come so we tried those on and bought those instead. Trevor and the other gentleman were great to work with, very helpful and knowledgeable with the stick in the store. Definitely would recommend this store for your used sports equipment.

They just tried to charge me $40 per Muay Thai pad, not as a pair. When I asked what would I do with just one he insulted my intelligences and said that's how the manufacturer sells them. When I showed him that's not true and a brand new pair can be delivered for $60 he dropped the price. Thanks the the desk I won't be shopping there. After reading the reviews this seems like q great business plan for Johnson County but all you need is a better workforce and a company like this could really thrive. Good idea for any other investors out there. Easy competition with this one. All you need is some hospitality and people who want to work there.

Edit** If Google would allow me to attach my picture then I gladly would. But it was a TriFlex Arm sleeve, so technically it is baseball, but you guys were all out of football sleeves, so for the sake of football pictures, we bought it for the night. I asked about the price, and your store associate at the counter said that the red tag was already marked down. This place used to be the go-to for all of our football needs, but nowadays the prices are way overpriced, especially for a second-hand store. Today when we went in, they had their 50% off red tag sale, and we were looking for a football sleeve for our son and found one and the tag said $19.99. We browsed a bit more before checking out, and when we got to the counter, we assumed that it would be only $10 since the tag clearly said $19.99, but we were informed that the price on the tag was already the final marked-down price. It was no big deal, so we still bought it, but on the way home, our son happened to peel back the red sticker, and lo and behold, the ORIGINAL sticker underneath was for the same EXACT price! Come on guys you could have at least spent the time to rip off the old sticker before trying to pull a "Target" and "Kohls" move on your customer. Absolutely shameful and definitely changes my view quite a bit of place.

My experience getting my glove relaced was disappointing. I dropped it off and received a call the next day that left me feeling judged for the glove I brought in. I don’t think I should have to justify my choice—I simply couldn’t afford a $300 glove after already spending hundreds to get my daughter everything she needed for her first softball season. After her season ended, I joined a league and noticed several others had the same glove. I just wanted to add a personal touch to make mine stand out a bit. When I picked it up after the weekend, I was underwhelmed by the quality of the work. The more I looked at it, the more it seemed like the job reflected the same dismissive tone from that earlier phone call—like it wasn’t worth their time to do it right. I’ve attached photos to show what I mean. *Update I have reuploaded photos*

As I customer I felt as if I wasn’t welcomed. No greeting as I enter the store, immediately eye contact from the woman that’s employed by this location. I say and watched how others were greeted as wanting this location. They were welcomed with smiles in addition to not being followed. As my daughter and I were shopping for my grandson a football helmet. My skin color was not at all welcomed at this location.

One of the people working there was very polite to my son. I appreciated that he took extra time to reach out and help my son. I would recommend this place to anybody.

We love going here. We usually find what we are looking for and the staff is helpful and friendly.