Goose The Market

From one week to the next, their sandwiches are half as big as they used to be. They did not lower the price, however. Two bites and you finish one half. If you are hungry, you will need to buy two sandwiches.

the food and selection there is amazing but the service definitely needs some work. i wasn’t greeted once or even asked how can we help you. it was my first time in there and i was just standing trying to understand the menu while the workers carried on their own conversations quite loudly. it was like no one had even walked in! the restaurant doesn’t have a spirit to it which is so sad as it is a local based restaurant which offers breads from local bakeries, fresh herbs and such. you would think the community aspect of their business would show up in their service too. i have friends who go their regularly but it’s not like they are regulars because the staff doesn’t interact much and isn’t super friendly. a kind interaction + a great sandwich would make this place 5 stars

I’ve had some incredible food here: a whole beer smoked chicken and their carrot cake gelato are things I still think about years later. Sandwiches are tasty. However I do think it’s overpriced, even for the quality. It doesn’t keep me from coming back, but it keeps it from being a regular spot. Also, the butchers are always friendly and helpful, but I’ve never had a good experience with the cashiers. Almost every interaction I’ve had at the register has felt like I’m bothering the staff with my patronage. This spot could easily become a great neighborhood joint, but the price and unfriendliness are probably the two things keeping it from being all that it could be.

The Deli: Upstairs, the experience is bright, friendly, and delicious. A wide selection of unique sandwiches with high-quality meats and cheeses. The muffaletta is a must-try. The staff is knowledgeable, helpful, and clearly takes pride in the food. The Bar: Descending a set of stairs transforms the atmosphere. The cellar is a hideaway with a completely different vibe, perfect for unwinding and conversations. The wine/beer selection is varied but focused.

Get the duck fat prosciutto and whatever cheese the person at the counter recommends. Seriously, the guy that helped us was incredible! Wabash Cannon Ball and Red Rock were my favorites from my first trip, but all of them were delicious! Next time we go we will definitely be getting sandwiches as well! They have everything you need for a unique charcuterie that will highlight local spots.

I ordered the Batali, sea salt cookie, and a chai latte. The cookie was so good not too much sugar but the right amount. The latte.. I dont think that it was prepared right. It tasted like pepper. The sandwhich was so good! Its super tiny but it filled me up. It's very crunchy and a little bit spicy. 8.5/10

I love this place to bits. I think they have best sandwiches in Indianapolis by a long shot. I’ll take the Goose Sandwich any day of the week and they also provide quick and warming service. I recently tried the butcher’s and the meats were phenomenal. I love everything about this place and thank you for such great service!