Indianapolis has become a haven for food enthusiasts, offering a rich tapestry of flavors that reflect its diverse culinary scene. Among its treasures, the selection of Italian dining establishments captures the essence of traditional and modern cuisine straight from Italy. Each restaurant provides a unique atmosphere and menu that showcases the heart and soul of Italian cooking, from handmade pasta to authentic pizzas, allowing diners to indulge in classic recipes that comfort and delight.
As you explore the city, you will discover that the Italian eateries of Indianapolis are not just places to eat but are culinary experiences that transport you to the Mediterranean. Whether you are looking for a cozy family-run trattoria or an upscale ristorante serving exquisite dishes, these top locales are sure to leave a lasting impression. With a commitment to quality ingredients and exceptional hospitality, these establishments embody the true spirit of Italian dining, making them essential stops for both locals and visitors alike.
Address
210 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46225, United States
Business Hours
Monday: 11:30–21:30
Tuesday: 11:30–21:30
Wednesday: 11:00–21:30
Thursday: 11:00–21:30
Friday: 11:30–22:30
Saturday: 11:30–22:30
Sunday: 11:30–21:30
Rating
9.3 (+ 3843 reviews)
The Old Spaghetti Factory offers a charming dining experience with a unique ambiance that transports you back in time. With its rustic decor and whimsical touches, it creates a delightful atmosphere perfect for family gatherings or casual dinners. The menu features a variety of pasta dishes that highlight fresh ingredients, ensuring satisfaction for every palate.
The service is consistently friendly and attentive, making diners feel welcome. From the moment you arrive until you leave, the staff is dedicated to enhancing your dining experience. If you’re looking for a place to enjoy comforting Italian cuisine and a warm atmosphere, The Old Spaghetti Factory is certainly worth a visit.
View Details
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Dinner reservations recommended
Customer Reviews
I am from out of town and this restaurant was recommended to me by a local friend. They didn’t steer me wrong.
The service and food were excellent.
If you’re not sure what to get, go with the Managers Special so you can try 2 types of sauce on your pasta. It’s definitely worth a visit.
Kyle McDowell
The atmosphere is really great here. Old school wood with a train car by the entrance. The lasagna was fresh and loved the various sauces. The salad and house bread were nothing special, but I loved the cotton candy drink, and the complementary spumoni was nice at the end.
Jennifer McDowell
We were greeted when we walked in. There wasn’t a wait. It’s a darker vibe in the restaurant. I’ve been wanting to try this spot out for a few years and was super excited just to be DISAPPOINTED. We had the garlic/cheese bread. It was too soft like it could’ve cooked for another 2 minutes or so. The spinach and artichoke dip lacked seasoning. I wished they would’ve buttered the bread. I tried adding crushed red pepper, salt, and pepper. It was still a no for me. He ordered shrimp alfrdedo. The shrimp had a very loud smell , and he couldn’t finish his food. I ordered fettuccine, and it also lacked seasoning. We both ordered strawberry lemonade. I asked for mine to be spiked and had NO IDEA that was going to cost me $21.50 for a drink. Never again. I was not happy at all. The bill was $80 for a bunch of nasty food. I planned on taking the food home to doctor it up because that was expensive and ended up giving it to a homeless man outside. I hope he enjoyed it more than I did. Unfortunately, we had to go somewhere else to eat and spend more money.
R. W.
We had much higher expectations for dinner. The food was mediocre and served warm,
Not hot at all. I’ve honestly had better chicken Marsala at home. We sat down and got our food within 20 minutes which means it’s almost all pre-prepared. If you are looking for a large portion and food that’s good, but not necessarily amazing, then this is for you. If you want really tasty, homemade pasta, this isn’t for you.
Erika LaPean (Party of 5 Adventures)
This place was such a treat we went twice! The place was dark, but really nice, the waiters, awesome sweet gals and the FOOD, incredible, this place with out a doubt gets the Red hat of approval, a must go to when you visit Indiana.
Hanzamapvp Universe
Address
3550 E 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46240, United States
Business Hours
Monday: 11:00–22:00
Tuesday: 11:00–20:00
Wednesday: 11:00–22:00
Thursday: 11:00–22:00
Friday: 11:00–23:00
Saturday: 11:00–23:00
Sunday: 11:00–21:00
Rating
9.0 (+ 3536 reviews)
Maggiano’s Little Italy offers a delightful dining experience that is both enjoyable and memorable. The ambiance is warm and welcoming, making it a perfect spot for any occasion. The staff is incredibly attentive, ensuring that diners feel well taken care of throughout their meal.
The food is simply exceptional, with generous portions that are ideal for sharing. Each dish is crafted with quality ingredients and full of flavor, leaving guests eager to return for more. Overall, Maggiano’s combines great service with delicious cuisine for an all-around wonderful outing.
View Details
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Lunch reservations recommended
Dinner reservations recommended
Free of charge street parking
Customer Reviews
My husband and I went to this location for Thanksgiving today and it was amazing! The restaurant was packed, atmosphere was festive, and the service was excellent. Our server, Keion, was the best. Our reservation was at 6:45 PM and it was very busy but he came over and treated us like we were the only table he had. He was kind, efficient, and very helpful! Each family-style course came out with perfect timing and we had so much food were able to take quite a bit home with us! We had an amazing experience and will definitely be back soon! Thank you!!
Jennifer Rice
First time here. At first we were told the wait would be 25-30 minutes. We walked outside and got on the 1st table app and it was 10 minutes. Then when we were seated the waitress told us they were shirt staffed. The place we sat was on an outside patio. I was very nice and relaxing. Our waitress was as attentive as she could be I guess. The food was very tasty. They brought me someone else’s order but luckily they ordered the same thing I did. I finally had leftovers so that should say something about portion sizes. They had a couple regular specials that made it economical. I would probably go back.
Tiffany Criss
We were stuck in traffic on the way to the hotel and decided to slip off the highway and grab some food. We decided to give this a shot in our comfy clothes (under dresses a tad). From the manager sitting us and blessing us with a wonderful appetizer to our waiter Martin taking such great care of us. He went over all the different menu options and what he thought we would like by our taste. He nailed it from the salads all the way to the dessert. When In the area this will always be a stop.
Amanda Seniour
This place is a MUST! Everything is beyond amazing! Save room for dessert!!! You can’t miss dessert! The lemon cookies are delectable and the cheesecake is the best I have EVER had. The bread that comes with dinner is scrumptious as well. We also tried the calamari as an appetizer and it was so good! Staff is very friendly as well. An all around pleasant experience!
Angie Randles
Good service very busy so you gotta pick chose when to go I went afternoon. Food was spot on fresh and good ingredients. It’s worth the drive I’ve been eating here for years. I’ve never had a bad experience. Parking is OK it can be overwhelming on a bad day. The servers are friendly. Definitely good spot for some food. 5 stars
Rustan Porter
Address
5646 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46219, United States
Business Hours
Monday: 11:00–21:00
Tuesday: 11:00–21:00
Wednesday: 11:00–21:00
Thursday: 11:00–21:00
Friday: 11:00–22:00
Saturday: 11:00–22:00
Sunday: 11:00–21:00
Rating
8.6 (+ 3527 reviews)
Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza offers an exceptional dining experience with its delicious menu that caters to pizza lovers. The unique combinations and fresh ingredients make each dish stand out, ensuring every bite is memorable. The atmosphere complements the food, making it a great spot for casual outings or gatherings with friends.
The service at Jockamo is truly commendable, as the staff are attentive and friendly, creating an inviting environment for all patrons. Whether you’re enjoying a meal in-house or ordering takeout, you can expect a satisfying experience that keeps you coming back for more. Don’t miss out on trying their specialty options!
View Details
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Free of charge street parking
Customer Reviews
Pizza was fantastic. The vibe is dope with lovely art on the walls. Wait staff were chill, but none of that matters. The only thing that matters is you try the stuffed peppadews. Heaven on earth. Go forth and eat at this delicious spot my friends.
Kevin Bryant
No Jockamo trip is complete without this spinach artichoke appetizer. I like it so much, I would marry it. Luau pizza is a must because pineapple in fact is delicious on pizza. Oh and the staff are 10s across the board.
Emily Grounds
Super good pizza, and I’m from Chicago. This location is my favorite and I go here every time I’m in Indianapolis even though I love on the North side of Indy now. Beer selection is great too.
nickarmani03
While the decor could use a little sprucing up, the food did not disappoint! We were a party of 12 & our server was great! We tried many small pizzas, breadsticks (no nacho chz ) & the meatball & ricotta app. NO COMPLAINTS!! If it wasn’t a 45 min drive I would definitely go back!
Tylena Knop
Too much cheese on the specialty pizzas!
I know that sounds silly right, isn’t pizza supposed to be all about the cheese? But, in this case, when you order the specialty pizza, with the special toppings, and the different flavors, having too much cheese on it is a disadvantage.
First, I loved the vibe of the place. If we were eating in, I love this space and this neighborhood. Also, everyone seemed very friendly. But we got the food to-go, to bring back to our Airbnb to watch the Purdue game!
I was so excited about this menu. It’s the execution that was a little bit off. I was also excited that they let me do a specialty pizza half-and-half.
I had half creole and half Bombay garden. I think they would’ve both done well to have very little cheese, because it didn’t seem to go with the rest of the flavor situation. In fact, the creole could’ve had no cheese, and just amped up on a creamy étouffée sauce as a cheese substitute. As it was, I felt like the cheeses overwhelmed all the really interesting elements of both pizzas.
In the future, please consider more masala sauce on the one pizza and more étouffée sauce on the second pizza, and a really light hand on the cheese. These are special ingredients, let’s not smother them with the cheese.
When we are back in Indianapolis, we will certainly give them another try, and tell them either no cheese or light cheese, because the menu is really quite special!
Lockie Hunter
Address
6130 E 82nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46250, United States
Business Hours
Monday: 11:00–22:00
Tuesday: 11:00–22:00
Wednesday: 11:00–22:00
Thursday: 11:00–22:00
Friday: 11:00–23:00
Saturday: 11:00–23:00
Sunday: 11:00–22:00
Rating
7.8 (+ 3194 reviews)
Olive Garden offers a delightful dining experience with a menu that highlights Italian cuisine. Guests often rave about the endless options, including the famous salad and warm breadsticks, which set the tone for a satisfying meal. The cozy ambiance combined with attentive staff creates a welcoming atmosphere that enhances any occasion.
The service is consistently praised, ensuring that diners feel valued and well-taken care of. Many enjoy trying new dishes from the extensive menu, while returning favorites never disappoint. For anyone craving a hearty meal and great hospitality, Olive Garden is a must-visit destination!
View Details
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Free of charge street parking
Customer Reviews
A Cozy and Delicious Experience at Olive Garden
We love popping into Olive Garden a couple of times a month for their classic soup, salad, and breadsticks combo. It’s the perfect spot for a casual meal with consistently good food, great service, and a cozy atmosphere.
Olive Garden has a nice selection of appetizers to start your meal off right. Some of our past favorites include the crispy Fried Calamari and creamy Spinach and Artichoke Dip served with warm pita bread. The Toasted Ravioli is also a delicious option.
However, this time, we decided to try something new and were pleasantly surprised by two fantastic appetizers: the Shrimp Fritto Misto and the Lasagna Fritta.
• Shrimp Fritto Misto: Lightly breaded and fried shrimp, paired with breaded peppers that added a wonderful balance of flavor and crunch.
• Lasagna Fritta: It’s hard to describe, but it’s definitely worth a try—fried lasagna with layers of creamy cheese and sauce, offering a unique and savory experience.
We thoroughly enjoyed both dishes and may have found some new favorites!
While the pasta dishes are always solid, we were here for the classic trio—soup, salad, and breadsticks. The fresh salad could easily be a meal on its own, with its crisp greens, tomatoes, olives, and tangy Italian dressing.
The highlight, though, is the Zuppa Toscana. This creamy broth is filled with spicy Italian sausage, tender kale, and russet potatoes—comforting, hearty, and incredibly flavorful.
The Dining Grandpa
Olive Garden is truly old school and every time I go I am never disappointed. The salad and breadsticks are always on point and the service is incredible. Ask for either Brittany or Nichelle they will get you right.
David Townsend
The portion are huge and tasty. quick service. Our server was amazing. the food had lots of flavor, offer had unlimited soup/bread.
rain drops
Julio is a wonderful waitor. I’m incredibly impressed with this food. It’s amazing! This location is very well taken care of. No messes, organized furniture & polite staff. I want to visit again very soon.
Spellbound Wolf
Great service from the beginning to the end. Leah is a very sweet and attentive waitress. I really enjoyed the chicken tortellini alfredo. The black tie mousse cake is a great dessert choice.
Linda Hanks
Address
225 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46204, United States
Business Hours
Monday: 07:00–15:00
Tuesday: 07:00–15:00
Wednesday: 07:00–15:00
Thursday: 07:00–15:00
Friday: 07:00–15:00
Saturday: 08:00–15:00
Sunday: 08:00–15:00
Rating
7.6 (+ 2748 reviews)
Café Patachou offers a delightful dining experience infused with a welcoming atmosphere perfect for any occasion. Guests enjoy a variety of delicious dishes that cater to diverse tastes, ensuring everyone leaves satisfied. The staff’s commitment to excellent service is evident, with attentive wait personnel ready to enhance your meal with recommendations.
The café stands out with its speedy food service without compromising on flavor. You can delight in items like cinnamon toast and various breakfast specials that promise to please. Overall, it’s an ideal spot for both locals and travelers seeking a remarkable breakfast experience in a relaxed setting.
View Details
Identifies as women-owned
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Customer Reviews
Relaxed atmosphere with a mix of tourists and workers sitting down for a good bite. We tried the we tried an item from the breakfast and lunch menu. The croissant French toast is delicious, but the club left much to be desired. The toddlers enjoyed delicious eggs and bacon, but the potatoes were hard. Definitely add the Paloma! Jeff made our dining experience EXTREMELY pleasant.He was professional & pleasant while explaining the menu and checked on us often throughout our meal. I highly recommend for a tasty breakfast when downtown Indianapolis.
Niecey Carter
The food was very delicious, the only thing we didn’t like was that the waiter came to our table about 10 times to see if we had finished, he didn’t even ask us if we wanted any dessert before bringing us the bill, this is because they want to clear the tables. . They do it to receive new customers waiting and get more tips, but that means they won’t let you have breakfast in peace. My friends and I had to wait about 40 minutes to enter, for them to want to get you out of there quickly is not a good idea for me.
Veronica Marz
Very delicious cinnamon toast $5.
Great spicy scrambled egg toast.
Good oat latte.
Coffee bar makes it easy.
French toast was excellent too! Not overly sugary.
Extremely efficient and a great breakfast. Food was served fast.
Albert K
Excellent food. Excellent service. The atmosphere was easygoing. I loved the self-serve complimentary coffee station while we waited for our drinks and meals. Their version of a BLT is awesome! The beer I had was very good too. All the drinks and coffee were good. The chocolate chip cookie i has was a huge surprise. I loved it. Just the right amount of salty sweet. I hope that cookie never leaves the menu. You get a fast food feeling while you are seated in there. Lots of hustle by the staff. Not to take anything away from the excellent service provided. I will definitely eat here the next time I visit Indiana for Fever basketball games.
rossifumifan1
The experience was great. I’m glad I got to try it as a solo diner.
The space wasn’t too busy and I was seated by the window. The food came out quickly after I ordered it. The server was kind and the food was good — not great. I got the waffle with a side of fruit.
I would come back here again. Probably to try their cinnamon toast.
Brizzle
Address
35 N Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46204, United States
Business Hours
Monday: 11:00–21:30
Tuesday: 11:00–21:30
Wednesday: 11:00–21:30
Thursday: 11:00–21:30
Friday: 11:00–22:30
Saturday: 11:00–22:30
Sunday: 11:00–21:00
Rating
6.6 (+ 2724 reviews)
Buca di Beppo offers an unforgettable dining experience with its generous portions and family-style meals that encourage sharing. The atmosphere is notably warm and inviting, perfect for gathering with friends or family over a delicious meal.
The service is exemplary, with attentive staff ready to make recommendations and accommodate needs. With its diverse menu full of flavorful Italian dishes, Buca di Beppo ensures that every visit is memorable. Diners can enjoy everything from classic pasta to mouthwatering appetizers that leave you longing for more.
View Details
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Lunch reservations recommended
Dinner reservations recommended
Paid multi-storey car park
Customer Reviews
Was in town from Texas for a work conference. My team decided to come here for dinner one night and we were not disappointed or didn’t leave with empty stomachs. Our waitress tried to warm us that the portions are large, and I do mean LARGE! The 4 us were able to feed off the few dishes we ordered and still had plenty leftover to pack. Service was outstanding! This place has a welcoming atmosphere home family feel. The price is totally worth it with the amount of food that is given. Everything had great flavor & the drinks were on point! Another great place to come to when you’re in town.
John Oliver
Nice Italian restaurant. Was looking for Pizza however, you won’t find it here. I visited during lunch and shopped the lunch menu as the remaining menu is family style. I opted for the Meatball sandwich (traditional style). Sandwich came with fries seasoned with garlic, black pepper and parsley. Both the sandwich and fries were good. The old fashioned I ordered was also done well. Slightly sweet, however still had a bourbon flavor. Pretty well balanced, however on the sweet side. My Daughter went with thr spaghetti and just said it was chunky with tomatoes but was good. Waitstaff was prompt and attentive. Decor goes for days and days…
C. Morgan
My family and I went there for my wedding reception. The food was terrific, and the atmosphere was decent. There was plenty of space to accommodate our 15-person family.
The server should have mentioned that you can only have one check when eating in a large group – which is inconvenient for many reasons -but for our group, we found out when we were ready to pay, which caused a whole thing. My brother-in-law paid with this credit card.
We had to recalculate all the items and divide the cost per person since everything was family-style and the wedding party sent the funds to him. That’s a lot of work to pay for your food on one of the most important meals of your life.
And the server “accidentally” ran up her tip before the dinner amount. Working through that was very frustrating, and I would have called for a manager had it not been a big day. The food is still great, though. I recommend that.
Leintz Belony
I was nearby for a conference, and we decided to go here for lunch. Great food and quick service. We enjoyed the family style serving where we could try out multiple dishes at our table.
Kevin Horst
This italian restaurant is located right at the monument circle, downtown Indy. The food, ambience, staff, drinks everything was amazing. Staffs are courteous. Portions are huge. Prices are a bit om upper side. But its worth it!! We tried fettucine alfredo, cheese ravioli and mozarrella. They tasted really yumm! Would recommend this hotel!
Sanchita
Address
329 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204, United States
Business Hours
Monday: 11:00–21:00
Tuesday: 11:00–21:00
Wednesday: 11:00–21:00
Thursday: 11:00–21:00
Friday: 11:00–22:00
Saturday: 11:00–22:00
Sunday: 11:00–21:00
Rating
6.5 (+ 2452 reviews)
Bazbeaux is a true gem for pizza lovers, offering a delectable selection that exceeds expectations. The blend of fresh ingredients creates a heavenly taste experience, and the crust is perfectly crispy, enhancing every bite. Patrons can revel in crafting their own custom pizzas or delight in the numerous specialty options available.
The warm and inviting atmosphere sets the stage for a delightful dining experience. Not only is the food exceptional and hot upon serving, but the friendly staff adds to the welcoming vibe. It’s a must-visit for anyone seeking quality pizza in a pleasant setting.
View Details
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Customer Reviews
Let’s talk pizza. There are a lot of pizza places in this country. First you have the retail chain spots, then you get to the real deal pizza. This is a real deal here. No frozen sent in from a factory to reheat pizza here. This is a great spot on Mass Ave. they have several specialty pizzas to choose from or make your own with the most available toppings I’ve seen for pizza. Nothing here is bad. The flavor is amazing, fresh and the food is served hot. As a special for me they do serve coca-cola products. If you follow me then you get that. The restaurant is clean . The staff is friendly and helpful. I highly recommend checking this place out.
Morgan Colyer
Came in here with high hopes but the atrocious service was too much to make it any way enjoyable. When you have to walk from your table to the bar to get help since your server hasn’t been to your table in 20 min – that’s too much.
The pizza is good at least. Thin and crispy crust.
But for all that’s good – have a training for your servers
Robert Cardoni
What a great pizza! Such a wonderful tomato taste. The crust was nice and crispy. I had gotten a mixed salad and they definitely did not skimp on the shaved Parmesan. The atmosphere was inviting and I am sure is really lively at night. I went in the afternoon for a late lunch. Parking is pay parking outside by meter. I think the only thing that would have made it better if there was a nice place to sit outside as the weather was amazing when I was there.
S D
Best frozen pizza I’ve ever had! It’s the only way to describe it. Great toppings, but the dough tastes like a frozen pizza.
Paul F.
We tried this place at the recommendation of a cousin and it did kot disappoint! The Cajun pizza was so good. The fresh mozzarella plate and the Bomba for dessert were also delicious!
adventures with FLY Frances Youngblood
Address
1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220, United States
Business Hours
Monday: Closed
Tuesday: Closed
Wednesday: Closed
Thursday: 17:00–21:30
Friday: 17:00–21:30
Saturday: 17:00–21:30
Sunday: Closed
Rating
6.2 (+ 2389 reviews)
Mama Carolla’s offers a delightful dining experience with a charming atmosphere and exceptional service. The cozy setting, reminiscent of a home, ensures a warm welcome as guests are attended to with care. Every visit promises to be memorable, making it a go-to destination for **Italian cuisine** lovers.
The menu is a delightful showcase of flavors, featuring dishes that leave a lasting impression. Diners rave about the **quality of ingredients** and the creativity that shines through each plate. With a focus on customer satisfaction, Mama Carolla’s truly stands out as a must-visit locale for anyone seeking a delightful meal.
View Details
Identifies as women-owned
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Free of charge street parking
Customer Reviews
My wife and I have never been here before and the place was packed. They don’t take reservations unless it is a large group and by the look of things; why should they? It would be nice to know you had a table but from their perspective; there is no need to the place was packed.
The restaurant is a small to medium size home that has been converted into Mama Carolla’s. They make use of all the space available to them. There are tables on the second floor and all the rooms on the lower level except in front door area where there is a small waiting room and in the back, where the kitchen is located. There is outdoor seating around the whole house even in the front yard.
Now the food. It was fantastic. The appetizer we had, stuff mushroom was great, there was only one, but I never tasted anything like it. My wife had a salad and rosemary chicken lasagna and she thought it was fantastic. I had the soup and I can’t remember the name of my entree but it had every kind of shell fish you can imagine on it, lobster, crab, clams, shrimp, scallops, and I’m sure there is something I’m forgetting, served with pasta in this unbelievable tangy sauce. She had wine and dessert, I had a Coke and Coffee and all this was less than $100, $88 to be exact. I can’t wait to go back
Larry Lynch II
First time eating in this lovely place. The atmosphere was awesome our waiter was awesome. He did an awesome job explaining the menus. Our food was delicious. We had an awesome time. Most definitely go visit again.
Imelda Figueroa
I was so excited to visit mama Carollas as I had heard so many great things about their food. It saddens me to say that this was the worst experience I’ve had in a restaurant, from the service to the food. The server we had was Chaz and he was very rude. The initial interaction was him pouring water in our glasses and he didn’t speak. I had to speak to him and ask if he would be our server, I also had to ask his name. He was not forthcoming with a warm welcome or his name. He laughed when I asked his name as if it was a ludicrous question. He never asked if it was our first time, didn’t suggests dishes, or make conversation of any kind. He had a very dry affect and was of no help. We had the calamari appetizer and the breading was not as crispy as we would like. The sauce that came with it was very strong and acidic. We had salad that came with our food and Chaz gave us 3 options of salad but never explained what the salad had in it, we had to ask. I ordered the chicken rigatoni and my family members had the carbonara and the bolognese. The bolognese tasted like chef boyardee and didn’t taste fresh. The carbonara was thick and noodles were linguini instead of spaghetti. It had way too much garlic and was not presented well. The chicken rigatoni was disgusting and tasted like vomit, I’m assuming the liquid in the dish was broth and it was not well liked by me . I told Chaz I was not happy with my food and asked for chicken piccata instead. The piccata was disgusting as well and my chicken was not fresh. The chicken looked like it was swimming in caper juice and I couldn’t even chew the chicken. I didn’t bother to taste the angel hair as it looked like mush and was thrown on the plate. All of the dishes had an orange slice which I didn’t understand. Myself and the guests I had with me expressed dislike for our meal and the manager was brought over. The manager who I now know is the owners son, Justin was very rude and had a dry affect as well. He asked what was wrong and I was kind in my response. He was tomato red and breathing heavily as if he was offended. Very unprofessional and was not kind toward us at all. Not once did he apologize for our dislike of our dinner, he didn’t tell us if he would comp the meal. I was nice enough to pay for my salad as I did eat that. He walked off without us knowing if there was a resolve or not. To add insult to injury, the dinner napkins smelled of old lady and dirty shoes. Of course our bread which was liked more than anything rested on the said napkins. Later we found out that the meal was comped. I will never return to this restaurant and I’m very disappointed. It’s one thing for us to not enjoy the meal but to be abrasive and rude was appalling. Once I researched the restaurant, I saw that Justin recently took over the restaurant with no experience in running a restaurant let alone cooking. He went from ramen noodles to Fazoli’s which is an insult to that establishment. Even though I didn’t enjoy the dinner I hoped that I could at least respect the service and resolution of our issue. I will not be returning but I hope Justin takes this criticism to be better in the future. Where is Gordon Ramsay when you need him. Calling kitchen nightmares immediately.
Ariele Mccauley
This is a fantastic spot for Italian cuisine. We sampled Misto Mare(seafood linguine), chicken piccata, calamari, Holly’s Artichoke Fritters, and ravioli, and everything was delicious. The service was outstanding. Despite the restaurant being busy, our food arrived promptly.
ASYPT
Favorite restaurant in indy. Beautiful atmosphere. Outside seating is to die for in the warm months. Cozy home vibe seating inside. The rosemary half chicken is wonderful and comes with a soup called Italian wedding which reminds me of a more elegant Campbell’s chicken noodle soup flavor. The staff are always welcoming and kind. Great tierramasu.
Angel Hutch
Address
43 N Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46204, United States
Business Hours
Monday: 11:00–22:00
Tuesday: 11:00–22:00
Wednesday: 11:00–22:00
Thursday: 11:00–22:00
Friday: 11:00–23:00
Saturday: 11:00–23:00
Sunday: 11:00–21:00
Rating
5.4 (+ 2026 reviews)
Giordano’s is a fantastic spot for enjoying delicious Italian cuisine. The service is impressive, with staff dedicated to ensuring customers have a satisfying experience. The menu offers a variety of options, making it ideal for a casual meal or a special occasion.
The food quality is unmatched, especially the deep dish pizza, which is a must-try. Patrons can expect generous portions, flavorful dishes, and an overall welcoming atmosphere that makes each visit enjoyable.
View Details
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Customer Reviews
There are all sorts of Italian places downtown, but this one is exceptional in terms of service and portion size. My personal pan sausage pizza was tantalizingly good. The side garlic fries were a flavor bomb. In addition, the server was top notch in making food suggestions and insuring her customers were well satisfied with their meal.
MaryAnn Spicer
Very nice place and atmosphere. Enjoyed the food..we got a deep dish pepperoni pizza, mozzarella triangle’s, and parmesan garlic fries. All were tasty. Service was very good.
Derek Hatfield
It was great overall! Place was nice and clean and we could sit without waiting. We ordered deep dish pizza and sodas. It took almost about hour to get the pizza but it was delicious. We enjoyed the food. People are nice there but seemed like they need more people to handle the peak time. I enjoyed the pizza and it was affordable and delicious 🙂
Jiyeon Portnoy
Went in for lunch. The place was clean and nit a lot of people. Seated promptly. Service was extremely delayed. The food was okay. Ghe Bruschetta had no seasonings. The pizza lacked flavor as well. They had run out of Moscato, so i ordered a sangria, which was ok. Not impressed.
Zeenat Joshi
Food and service was great. Be prepared to wait 45 minutes for the deep dish pizza. They held our table while we went across the street and shopped. Very friendly service and pizza was great
Christina Reynolds
Address
946 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46225, United States
Business Hours
Monday: 11:00–14:30, 16:00–21:00
Tuesday: 11:00–21:00
Wednesday: 16:00–21:00
Thursday: 11:00–14:30, 16:00–21:00
Friday: 11:00–14:30, 16:00–22:00
Saturday: 16:00–22:00
Sunday: 16:00–20:00
Rating
5.1 (+ 1824 reviews)
Iozzo’s Garden of Italy offers a truly exceptional dining experience characterized by outstanding service and a warm atmosphere. The staff is incredibly attentive, ensuring that your glass is always filled and that every need is met with a friendly smile. This commitment to customer satisfaction makes every visit memorable.
The menu features a remarkable array of Italian dishes that are both flavorful and well-prepared. Each plate reflects a genuine passion for culinary excellence, making it a prime choice for Italian cuisine enthusiasts. From appetizers to entrees, the quality of food truly shines, making it an unmissable dining destination.
View Details
Identifies as women-owned
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Lunch reservations recommended
Dinner reservations recommended
Free of charge street parking
Customer Reviews
As an avid Italian food eater and a bias for NJ/NY having the best food in the country, this place could easily compete. First of all, the service. Your water glass will never be empty. They take customer service very seriously and want to make your dining experience as pleasurable as possible. Next the food! The minute you walk into the restaurant you can just smell an aroma of garlic bread. So of course, we ordered it as an appetizer. It was delicious, cheesy and fantastic. We also ordered crispy calamari that came with two dipping sauces that were a great compliment. Lastly for our entrees we ordered the chicken parm dinner with a substitution of vodka sauce. Out of this world! The food was delicious, the portions were great. This is a great spot in a great location in Indianapolis.
Christopher Frometa
Ambience is simply perfect- Cozy, elegant and ideal for relaxing meal. As a vegetarian , it was hard to find good options for Italian food but they were able to accommodate request and every dish we ordered was fresh, flavorful and crafted with care. The highlight of the experience was undoubtedly the caring serving staff. The staff were friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable. Might need to add some table salt or pepper as per your taste buds but overall food was unique and great quality. Street parking and as well as parking on back of the restaurant. Highly recommended reservation. Smoke free environment. Wheelchair accessible.
Krunal Shah
We visited this location for the first time for a family birthday. We had a reservation for five people. They had our table ready for us when we arrived. The service was wonderful. Our waiter spent quite a bit of time explaining things on the menu and answering our questions. The food was wonderful. Each one of us had a different entree and there was nothing that was bad. We also got calamari and the cheese bread for appetizers. They boxed up our leftovers for us. And they are able to package up any leftover wine from their bottle service for you to take home. The atmosphere was quaint and cozy.
Andi Robinson
Nice restaurant, very limited seating inside, but all in all, a good place to have dinner. Reservations are a must, so make yours as soon as possible. We sat outside for dinner, and it was a nicely decorated area and had plenty of shade. Staff was great and knowledgeable of the menu. Would definitely come back.
Alfonzo Leathers
This is a nice hidden gem. It’s nestled right on the outskirts of downtown and definitely worth the trip. It’s not a really big place but it gives really cozy vibes. Our waitress was very informative and patient being it was our first visit. We ordered a couple of different things and they all were great. If you’re looking for Italian food downtown this is the perfect place to visit.
J C
How to find your ideal italian restaurant at the best price in Indianapolis?
Request help now to find the best price:
- Fill in the details and tell us what you're looking for
- We locate the best italian restaurant in Indianapolis near you
- The company contacts you
Catalog of services offered by Italian restaurants in Indianapolis
Authentic Italian Cuisine
Italian restaurants in Indianapolis pride themselves on serving authentic Italian cuisine. Diners can expect a variety of traditional dishes such as handmade pasta, risottos, and classic sauces made from fresh ingredients, creating a genuine taste of Italy right in the heart of the city.
Pizza Variety
One of the highlights of any Italian dining experience is the variety of pizzas available. From Neapolitan-style thin crust to deep-dish options, these restaurants offer a delicious range of toppings, ensuring there is something for everyone, whether you prefer classic Margherita or adventurous combinations.
Wine Pairing and Selection
To complement the rich flavors of Italian dishes, restaurants in Indianapolis offer an extensive wine selection. Knowledgeable staff can provide wine pairing recommendations that enhance the dining experience, allowing guests to explore exquisite Italian wines that match their meals perfectly.
Daily Specials and Seasonal Menus
Many Italian restaurants feature daily specials and seasonal menus that highlight fresh, local ingredients. Guests can enjoy unique dishes that change regularly, showcasing the creativity of the chefs and the best produce available throughout the year.
Takeout and Delivery Services
For those who prefer enjoying their meals at home, Italian restaurants often provide takeout and delivery services. This convenience allows diners to savor their favorite dishes, be it pasta, pizza, or desserts, in the comfort of their own homes without sacrificing quality or taste.
Family-Friendly Dining
Many Italian establishments in Indianapolis focus on creating a family-friendly dining atmosphere. They offer diverse menus that cater to all ages, including children's portions and lighter options, ensuring that families can enjoy a delightful meal together.
Event Catering and Private Dining
Italian restaurants frequently provide event catering and options for private dining. Whether it’s a birthday, wedding, or corporate event, these services ensure that guests can celebrate with delicious food in an inviting atmosphere, offering tailored menus to suit individual preferences.
Cooking Classes and Culinary Experiences
For those interested in learning the art of Italian cooking, some restaurants offer cooking classes and culinary experiences. Participants can engage directly with chefs to learn how to prepare traditional dishes, enhancing their culinary skills while indulging in the Italian culinary tradition.
Frequently asked questions about italian restaurants in Indianapolis
What types of cuisine can I expect at Italian restaurants in Indianapolis?
Italian restaurants in Indianapolis typically offer a wide variety of traditional dishes, ranging from pasta and pizza to seafood, meat dishes, and vegetarian options. You can find classic sauces such as marinara, alfredo, and pesto, along with fresh ingredients that highlight the authenticity of Italian cuisine.
Are there Italian restaurants in Indianapolis that offer gluten-free options?
Many Italian restaurants in Indianapolis are becoming more accommodating and do offer gluten-free options. This can include gluten-free pasta and pizzas, as well as other dishes that can be modified. It is recommended to check the menu or inquire with the staff about specific dietary needs when visiting.
What is the average price range of Italian restaurants in Indianapolis?
The average price range of Italian restaurants in Indianapolis can vary widely depending on the restaurant's ambiance and offerings. Casual eateries might offer meals in the $10-$20 range, while more upscale restaurants could feature entrees priced between $20-$50 or more. Always check the menu beforehand to get a sense of the pricing.
Do Italian restaurants in Indianapolis accept reservations?
Many Italian restaurants, especially those that are popular or located in busy areas, do accept reservations. It’s advisable to make reservations, particularly during peak dining hours or on weekends, to ensure a table is available. Some restaurants may also operate on a first-come, first-served basis, so it’s best to call ahead.
What are some popular Italian dishes to try in Indianapolis?
Some popular Italian dishes that are often highlighted in Indianapolis restaurants include lasagna, osso buco, risotto, and various forms of ravioli. Additionally, you may find authentic wood-fired pizza, antipasto platters, and decadent desserts like tiramisu or panna cotta.
Are there vegetarian options available at Italian restaurants?
Yes, many Italian restaurants in Indianapolis offer a range of vegetarian options. This may include pasta dishes that are designed without meat, as well as salads, bruschetta, and vegetable risottos. You can also often find a selection of cheese-based pizzas that cater to vegetarian diets.
Do Italian restaurants offer takeout or delivery services?
Most Italian restaurants in Indianapolis offer takeout and some may also provide delivery services. This can be a convenient option for those who wish to enjoy their favorite dishes at home. It’s recommended to check the specific restaurant's website or call to confirm their takeout and delivery options.
Can I find family-friendly Italian restaurants in Indianapolis?
Absolutely, many Italian restaurants in Indianapolis are family-friendly and offer children's menus. These restaurants often have a casual atmosphere with items that appeal to all ages, making them great venues for family dining. Look for restaurants that promote a welcoming ambiance and have high chairs or changing facilities available.
Are there Italian restaurants with outdoor seating in Indianapolis?
Yes, several Italian restaurants in Indianapolis offer outdoor seating, especially during the warmer months. This allows guests to enjoy their meals in an al fresco setting, which can enhance the dining experience. It’s advisable to check if outdoor seating is available and whether it requires a reservation.
What is the best way to find Italian restaurants in Indianapolis?
The best way to find Italian restaurants in Indianapolis is to use online review platforms such as Yelp or Google Reviews, along with local food blogs and recommendation websites. Searching for restaurants based on location and customer ratings can provide a comprehensive view of the best Italian dining options available in the area.
